<p>I find the criticisms of my pointing out the manner in which Oxford JC does, and always will, act as the Emory Anchor sophomoric, laughable & the product of young minds w/o any exposure to the “real” world. If someone dislikes my noting the absurdity of Emory having its own little JC, I’m either a “■■■■■”, not using quantifiable or at least empirical evidence or, as a last resort, given the “rankings don’t matter” BS. </p>
<p>I think there is much that can be seen by present (or recent) students at Emory that is of value. Certainly, I had to “go back to the numbers” on OJC, which resulted in a partial reassessment on my part of the JC. It is far more diverse than I had thought, and the admission standards have gone up. The student body is still made up of Emory rejects taking a back-door to an Emory degree, but Oxy’s are now a far higher standard of rejects. The JC (and, by the way, what else do you call a 2 yr. college?) should be applauded for its efforts. However, a better grade of student body in no way justifies its useless & anachronistic relationship with Emory. </p>
<p>It would be easy to cite personal anecdotal experience regarding the fundamental unfairness of students unable to gain entry to Emory nonetheless managing to scam a degree via Ox. I have 30 yrs experience past College, including a professional degree from EU, a graduate degree from Vandy, and ten (10) yrs of re-paying student loans. I have lived throughout the South, and travelled widely as part of business. I have a better understanding of the “value” of degrees than someone at Ox, Emory, or a few years out of Emory. </p>
<p>Further, my motivation(s) regarding an anti-OJC stance derive from being pro-Emory. I watched Emory’s national reputation grow for many years, and was proud of that. I knew from being at Vandy, as well as experiences at colleges as prestigious as Dartmouth and Michigan, that Emory undergrad was more rigorous and just plain better than most other colleges. I learned a lot at EU, generally had great professors, and after many years of coming into contact with other educated folks realized how privileged I had been to attend Emory. To graduate Magna Cum Laude & Phi Beta Kappa was nice when I was 22, it was only after years of working and then having kids of my own that I truly appreciated the “value” of those things. It is that realization which actuates my continuing criticism of what plainly is a back door to Emory.</p>
<p>If people like y’all can’t grasp the problem with Oxford, you will. That is, unless you went to Oxy. If you can’t understand the problem in Notre Dame passing Emory, or Vandy clearly becoming the #2 private university in the South, you will. If things continue on the present course, in 20 yrs you will see Wake Forest and William & Mary pass Emory. If you don’t think it can happen, just keep the Tulane “model” in mind. Thirty years ago Tulane was at or near Emory’s equal in ranking & prestige. Now it’s not even a Top 50 school. And it’s decline was ongoing way before Katrina hit New Orleans. I have known Tulane people, one or two quite well, and saw up close how the declining “value” of their degrees effected them. And I mean personally and professionally. </p>
<p>Emory needs to stop its potential decline it rankings, now. The law school, business school & medical school continue to move up, and there’s no reason the college cannot do likewise. Saying rankings don’t matter is BS. Saying if it were not for Ox Emory would have a lower quality of Freshmen class is BS (actually, it’s so stupid it’s rather sad). When I was at Emory we truly believed the school would, in a decade or so, match up with Washington U. and Northwestern. Emory needs to get back to that belief, and part of that is recognizing the appendage known as “Emory at Oxford” either needs to go, or to be re-shaped into an educational entity that inures to Emory’s credit, and its prestige. There are things that can be done, but historically the Oxy crowd (alum) have blocked efforts to bring Oxy even into the 1980’s. </p>
<p>Right now, I am watching kids, & their parents w/choices in “Top 20 schools” (and I include Amherst, Williams, Swarthmore, etc.), and I have been surprised & disturbed concerning what I continue to hear about Emory. In fact, I am embarrassed. Do something or be prepared to take the hit. And “something” includes addressing the chuckling I hear when certain schools competitive w/Emory start talking about Emory having a JC.</p>