Transfer Essay #2

<p>Hrm, after the negative feedback from my first essay I whipped up another one, answering the question, "What is your greatest achievement?" It's still my first draft so if you could make any suggestions with regard to sentence structure/flow then feel free to do so.</p>

<p>I would appreciate any feedback/comment, and names have been changed for anonymity.<br>
My current concern is that the subject of my essay might be a little trite, and that it is a bit too long.</p>

<hr>

<p>Late Friday afternoon. It’s the time of the week when everyone is in a good mood because his weekend is about to start. “Hey Andy we’re going out after school to catch a movie, you coming? (Slaps his head in exaggerated motion) Oh that’s right, you have your violin lesson then,” a friend teases with obvious Schadenfreude. Truth be told, the only reason I kept up with my violin was because of the music scholarship – or so I convinced myself. It was therefore almost humorous when my teacher asked that afternoon, “So, I know you’ve got your AMUS exams (a performance exam for musicians given by the Australian Music Examinations Board) this year. I think it’d be a great help to your playing if you performed at the mid-year school concert.” I replied almost immediately that I didn’t think so, but being one of the most stringent teachers at the school (his orchestra rehearsals were famous for their never-ending finishes), he dismissed my protests, “Nonsense. I’ll talk to the music director. Now let’s see which piece you should prepare for the concert…” An hour and a half later I was back home with the score for Vivaldi’s ‘Spring’ in my hand.</p>

<p>Couple of months later. As the date of the concert approached I kept thinking of new excuses which would prevent me from playing in the concert: a severe paper cut, a sudden illness, a sprained wrist from lunchtime soccer. I probably spent more time coming up with plausible excuses than actually practicing for the concert. In addition, two months of familiarizing with the music meant that I was relatively comfortable with most parts of the piece. ‘If worst comes to worst and I actually have to play in the concert,’ I thought to myself, ‘I can just play it as it is now.’ My teacher however was far from satisfied, especially with my stagnant progress. There was a particular section in the piece (the ‘Storm’ section of the first movement for those familiar with the music) which, no matter how many lessons were devoted to, did not improve over time. When it came time to rehearse with the orchestra, things did not change; the rapid notes in the Storm section still eluded my fingers. After several weeks of no improvement I resigned to the fact that I was simply going to make a mistake on the day of the concert. </p>

<p>Two days before the concert. It was my final lesson, and although the other parts were almost perfect (through Spartan repetition), the technically advanced ‘Storm’ section still did not allow itself to be controlled by my fingers; although there was some improvement, it was far from a perfect storm. My teacher, frustrated at my resignation, said with exhaustion, “Maybe it’s a mental thing. Every time you know that section is coming, you tense up and tell yourself that you can’t do it. You’ve practiced enough, and this piece isn’t that much more difficult than other pieces you’ve played.” I replied that it’s just a small section of the piece, and it wouldn’t matter too much if I made mistakes just in that section. “Every section, every note is important,” he responded with obvious annoyance, “you can’t just ignore a particular section and expect to say that what you played was Vivaldi’s ‘Spring.’” I refuted by saying that there was nothing more I could do, that I had tried at least. “Can you honestly say that you’ve really tried?” I had no answer.</p>

<p>Great accomplishments are realized through achieving something – something that isn’t necessarily extraordinary – through truly trying. I can say that during those two days, I truly practiced (not the mundane repetitive finger exercise that I had called ‘practice’ before), taking each note apart and practicing slowly at first, gradually building up to the desired tempo. No one was more amazed than myself when things finally clicked into place, and I was able to project with clarity each of the storming notes, at whatever tempo I wished. Before the performance – and during the leading sections of the performance – I knew that I could perfectly play that section – and I did. I did make one mistake on different section however, during a relatively easy part near the end, on which I had never made a mistake previously. It wasn’t a huge mistake, but enough to prevent the performance from being a perfect one. After the performance, my teacher was the first to congratulate me, and his proud smile said much more than mere words. I told him about the mistake I made, but he questioned with genuine surprise, “what mistake?” When I insisted that I was sure that I had made a mistake, he replied that sometimes performers unconsciously learn to cover their mistakes, so the audience never notices it. Indeed, my mother said that she did not hear any mistake, nor did anyone else I asked. Later when I listened to the video-recording of my performance, I could definitely hear the mistake. I pointed this out to my mother (who was a musician herself) but she said that during the performance my playing was so confident that it did not seem like a mistake at all, and she was right. I could definitely hear the mistake, but I couldn’t see it. Seeing myself perform – not just play – in front of hundreds of people, seeing myself achieve something, I knew that my performance had been perfect.</p>

<p>before I read this I wanted to ask you if you know whether the essays should have a title? aslo schools you are sending this to, as yale sees thing differently from upenn for example. thanks.</p>

<p>Haven't really thought of a title. I'm sending this to Yale for their generic essay (tell us something about yourself type essay)</p>

<p>i don't understand what this says about you</p>

<p>Truth be told, this was originally written for the Stanford APP (which was pretty explicit: "Describe your greatest accomplishment"), but I thought it might work for the generic Yale one</p>

<p>bump (this is OP.. wont let me log for some reason)</p>

<p>I like this essay. It IS too long (and I don't necessarily mean for the character limit, but that it gets overly detailed in some spots) and therefore loses some of its impact and its main message. You can probably edit it yourself, but if you want suggestions, PM me with your email address.</p>

<p>Is your everyday speech really peppered with phrases such as "a friend teases with obvious Schadenfreude" and "through Spartan repetition". This essay kind of reminds me of Dennis Miller when he was on Monday Night Football. His references were so obscure and devoid of humor, nobody thought he was funny except for himself.
I'm not saying you have to "dumb it down" a bit, but your references are so unnatural, it is obvious that the only reason you included them is to impress an AdCom.
I assume you posted this essay because you wanted constructive criticism and not a "pat on the back". Please don't take my comments personally, I'm just trying to help turn a good essay into a great one. If you're applying to Stanford and Yale, you'll need it.</p>

<p>Thanks for your comments. I did not choose those words to impress and adcom, but rather because I felt that those phrases express most appropriately what I am trying to convey (after all, the those words exist because they are to be used in certain situations right?) If it seems so unnatural, could you maybe suggest other ways of phrasing it? (If I sound defensive I apologize, but I am genuinely interested in how you would change those sentences. And could you maybe elaborate on why they seem unnatural?)</p>

<p>And whether I speak like this in every day speech... no I do not. If I were to write as I would speak normally... then every sentence would have at least 3 swear words lol. This however, IS my 'writing voice' and I think it is incorrect for you to judge the way someone writes on two sentences. For example, does one obscure reference mean that the whole essay becomes obscure? </p>

<p>Again, I apologize if I sound overly defensive, and your criticism was not taken personally. But I honestly feel that those words do not feel 'out of place' or 'unnatural' (I am relatively famliiar with the contextual possibilities of both words).</p>

<p>I guess trying to convince you that those words are malapropos is a Sisyphean task!!!!!
Keep in mind, I don't have the rest of your application on which to make a judgement. If you have scored in the top percentile on your SATs and have a shelf full of Pulitzers, I wouldn't question the words because they would fit into the overall context of your application.
You are correct, those words were invented so that people could use them, but if the reader doesn't know the German and Greek references, the effect is lost. You're gambling that the AdCom is aware of those meanings (or at least will take a few minutes to look them up on Wikipedia).</p>

<p>Hrm, I think maybe I'll just change the word Schadenfreude... Spartan is a pretty commonly used word though yeah?</p>

<p>Spartan I knew....Schaden@#$%^&whatever I had to look up :)
As I said before, it's a good essay, just trying to make it better.</p>