Ucbalumnus: "The state of Alabama has a 26.7% black population, versus 11.5% at the University of Alabama and 7.1% at Auburn University. The state of Florida has a 16.8% black population, versus 6.8% at the University of Florida and 8.2% at Florida State University.
That by itself does not say much either way about whether there is more or less racism at these universities, although black students are underrepresented in both states’ best known universities. The reasons for that are more complex than can be explained quickly in this thread, though they could relate to both current racism in society and/or historical legacy of past racism.
If you are south Asian, then you will likely be perceived as an outsider when it comes to anyone’s (sometimes misguided or stereotyped) assumptions about white or black people."
Ok, let’s break it down. First, your data is incorrect, just a little, but I think correct data is crucial. The Black population at UA is 12.3%, not 11.5% of its entire enrollment ( hmmm, maybe there has been an increase from the data point you referenced). And notice I emphasized that the percentage of Blacks at those other SOUTHERN schools has greatly declined. See http://savvyroo.com/story-1898766627559-decline-in-minority-enrollment-in-florida-university-system for data about the state of Florida. That was the focus of my argument, not on whether any of these schools enroll anything close to the actual percentage of Blacks in their respective states, including Alabama’s rival Auburn, which somehow, never receives any flak for racial problems. My point is not to imply that there is no issue with race at UA, just that it is strange to focus so much attention on it at UA when the Black enrollment there shows no signs of declining.
But let’s say that there was no affirmative action at most of the nation’s top schools, especially ones in Northern and Western states. Do you have any idea what the percentage of Blacks at these schools would be without affirmative action? Yes, the disparity between Black enrollment at state schools vs. percentage of Black people in respective states could partially be due to racism, but I think it is dangerous to treat Blacks as perpetual victims. One major problem with your thesis is the fact that lower income Whites have an average SAT that is lower than the average SAT of both all Blacks AND upper income Blacks. See http://www.jbhe.com/features/49_college_admissions-test.html This points to cultural factors that must be examined if there is to be progress in closing the gap. It is not always the fault of Whites. But I suspect you already know that, even it it is not politically correct to admit it.
Again, why has the percentage of Blacks at UA stayed above 12 % while that at other Southern schools, not to mention other region’s schools, is declining? The media portrays UA as one of the last bastions of racism. Wouldn’t we expect some significant decline in Black enrollment at UA if the environment at UA for Blacks was particularly bad? My argument cuts to the heart of this meme.
See post #33 for a correction by the author. - FC