UC Personal Statement Critique Wanted

<p>I'm not sure if my essay is what UC colleges look for in a personal statement or colleges in general. I have not had much writing experience, so any constructive criticisms (especially about the topic choice, grammar, and overall flow) are greatly appreciated.
Thank You!</p>

<p>Essay:
As I sent my best glare in the direction of the disgustingly self-righteous girl, I hoped that the words wouldn't stumble on their way to defend the girl I had met not ten minutes earlier. </p>

<p>I grasped the arm rest of the car door as the flag pole came into view. Unlike my friends, who I had known since Kindergarten, I was attending a different intermediate school for a more challenging education. Although I was just a few miles away from my childhood friends, I knew I would rarely or never see them. Grimacing as harsh reality slapped me again, I made my way down the unfamiliar halls.</p>

<p>By the time it was recess, I felt very much like a turtle who had misplaced its shell. To summarize my morning, I went to my art class instead of band first. So, when the art teacher couldn't find my name on his roster, he sent me to the office. I must have looked distraught because they sent me to a counselor who escorted me to the band room. When the bell rang, I was relieved I would finally get some fresh air and enjoy a snack.
As I stood outside the band room, I watched the various groups of students around me, eager to hear about the two weeks that they had spent apart. Then, in my peripheral vision, I saw a girl walk toward me and lean against the railing next to me. What caught my interest was her unusual attire; I saw the unmistakable shape of a muʻumuʻu, a simple, old-fashioned Hawaiian dress, complete with the familiar elastic sleeves, eyelet frills, and ribbons around the bottom. Noticing my glance, she did a friendly wave and said “Hi, my name is Kat.” After the awful experience I had that morning, I welcomed any friend who could help me adjust to my new surroundings. “Hi, my name is Kellie. I like your dress; it reminds me of the ones I used to wear when I was small.” Kat asked me about where I came from and which classes I was taking. She was one year older than me and was only taking the art class. </p>

<p>Next, a scene that I thought only existed in movies played out before me. A group of girls were marching our way toward the snack shop when suddenly the girl in the front stopped in front of us with a scowl of disgust. Criticism burned in her eyes as she glanced up and down Kat’s dress. Finally, her expression smoothed over and in a matter-of-fact voice she said, “Why the hell do you dress this way? It’s so weird.” Kat’s shoulders seemed to shrink and she looked down, embarrassed. Like a zoologist discovering a new species for the first time, I was astonished that bullies even existed. Before they could slither away, I snapped out of the trance, retorted “She can dress however she wants to.” The leader of the pack did a double take, looking stunned. Regaining control of her expression, she glared at me then stalked away. “You didn't need to say anything. Now they’ll think you’re strange too.” Kat whimpered. I uttered one of the greatest aphorisms my father told me, “What other people think of me is none of my business.”</p>

<p>I believe that in one’s most vulnerable times, one’s true nature is revealed. That day, I found my true character, who I was and would always be. I am confident that wherever my goals make take me, unfamiliarity and the lack of a social circle, will not hold me back. Just as I enjoyed the conversation with Kat, I take delight in hearing the experiences of others and sharing my own. I feel that if I hear and understand someone else’s experience I gain some experience myself, and vice versa. My true nature is what drives me to leave familiar territory for college and pursue a degree in computer science, a field that I am very passionate in, but still know little about. In the search for experience, I am confident that the Universities of California can provide me with the education, environment, and peers to grow.</p>

<p>I don’t know how admission officer at UC will view this essay
I think it is interesting and gives an idea of who you are. All in all, I think it is good.</p>

<p>I think you come across as superior and confrontational. There were other ways to handle the situation which could have resulted in new friends for you and Kat. Even if you disagree and think your actions were brave, there are more interesting situations to display that. </p>

<p>How did you “delight in hearing the experiences of others” and “hear and understand someone else’s experience” with the bullies? </p>

<p>While Kat may have been happy to have you as her protector (or not), your approach wouldn’t often lead to improved harmony at the school and thereby make you someone the reader would seek out.</p>

<p>@CHD2013
Ah, I see you’re point. Would you recommend changing to a different story all together or reshaping this one?</p>

<p>It would choose a different topic. PM me if you’d like for some more specific advice.</p>

<p>I stopped reading it after the first few sentences. This isn’t a novel, it’s a personal statement.</p>

<p>I agree with @bomerr…you got to go bit more into your ECs, not your interaction with your friend, and not sure how it relates to your CS major either.
[UC Davis</a> : Personal Statement](<a href=“http://admissions.ucdavis.edu/apply/personal_statement.cfm]UC Davis”>http://admissions.ucdavis.edu/apply/personal_statement.cfm)
<a href=“http://www.eaop.uci.edu/PDF/handouts/Personal%20Statement%20WS%2009.pdf[/url]”>http://www.eaop.uci.edu/PDF/handouts/Personal%20Statement%20WS%2009.pdf&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>I really dont think you have a chance to get into a UC with a personal statement like this. First , it does NOT answer any of the prompts that have been given for freshman nor transfer students, so i dont know how you will be able to submit that to a UC.
the whole thing sounds like a 15 y.o girl writting about herself in a journal, and Im really not trying to be harsh since I am writting my UC P.S too and understand how hard it is to convey ideas eloquently in 500 words but this is very badly written and the story is extremely pointless, You even had dialogue in there! huge no for a PS.<br>
Good luck but i think that for a UC you need to have way better writting skills than that</p>

<p>Are all those adverbs and.adjectives necessary?</p>

<p>Don’t listen to lamelcriada.</p>

<p>I’m applying to some UCs too; your essay isn’t bad, it just needs work. For one, I would cut out quite a bit of the first half, given that the fact that you’re at a new school really has little to do with the point of your essay. I think you’re answering UC prompt #2, so I’d focus more on the last paragraph, which is the only point at which you even discuss why that experience was important. Expand on that paragraph.</p>