<p>Rlmmail:</p>
<p>You asked: “If Brown or Penn were in Chicago, is it possible they might not have found it so important to lure chain stores to their campus gates?”</p>
<p>My answer is, that depends on WHERE in Chicago those schools would be located.</p>
<p>Look, a big issue with UChicago is that, yes, virtually everything available in a world-class city is available to UChicago students, BUT, to be frank, students need to be tolerant of considerable travel times. Some possible scenarios:</p>
<p>Say a student in South wants to go to the world-class art institute. According to Google, via public transportation, this is a: 40 minute one-way trip on a weekday.</p>
<p>To get to the shops around north michigan avenue, the trip would be about 45 minutes one-way as well. </p>
<p>Say a student wants to go to the northside for dinner/a show/whatever. According to Google, via public transportation, this is a: 55-60 minute one-way trip.</p>
<p>Say a student wants to go to a Bulls game or Blackhawks game. Via public transportation, this is a: 60 minute one-way trip.</p>
<p>It’s not unreasonable for college students to want to make use of all these big-city resources. The fact that, for the most popular areas (outside of maybe Chinatown) that UChicago students would like to frequent take between 40 -60 minutes (one-way) is worthy of consideration. Frankly, it makes Hyde Park feel a bit isolated and like an island.</p>
<p>A huge reason for this is that there is no subway stop right near UChicago, unlike what you see at Harvard, Penn, Columbia, etc. This sad fact really changes the accessibility of resources for UChicago students, especially those without a car. </p>
<p>So, to answer your question, if Brown or Penn were in Hyde Park and the closest Gap was 55 minutes away via public transport, then yes, I think those schools would plan differently. </p>
<p>UChicago students eager to enjoy the big city need to have considerable tolerance for long travel, and should be aware that it can be a long, long trip to get to some of the most popular areas of the city. Couple this fact with the reality that Hyde Park is still generally a sleepy, residential neighborhood, and you begin to see a very different neighborhood than Cambridge or West Philly or Morningside Heights. </p>
<p>College students at UChicago are in a more muted neighborhood AND with considerably longer commute times to get to popular amenities (be it rows of bars, the museums, etc.).</p>