Unreasonable TOEFL requirement.

Hello, I have an issue with some TOEFL policies with FIT (Fashion Institute of Technology). FIT is my first choice and they recently sent me an email stating that in my application I am required to provide TOEFL scores otherwise my application that I worked so hard on won’t be even looked at. I need help because my situation is different than students that are non-citizen and studied abroad.

I lived in the US for more than 5 years now, I came here in March 2010, I spent 2 years in US middle school P.S. I.S. 187 Hudson Cliff and currently completing my 4th year in Fiorello LaGuardia High School of Performing Arts.

During my first year in High School I got an extra English class (ESL), however during all the years present in the US I’ve completed not only 3 years of ESL but also 6 years of basic English. ESL was my extra English class. I’ve passed all of my English classes, I’ve taken English regents and got a 90 on it (it is officially on my transcript) I just don’t understand how is that not enough to prove that my English is proficient. I’ve called the Office of Admissions at FIT and asked them why am I required to take TOEFL and she said that it is because I have ESL class listed in my transcript.

I then visited their website once again and checked TOEFL requirements and it said “Students who have completed less than four years of English (not ESL) at a U.S. high school are required to take the TOEFL, IELTS, or PTE.” I do not meet that criteria therefore I don’t need to take TOEFL. Like I’ve mentioned before all the years I’ve spend in High School Ive been taking a standard English class each year. Only in my Freshmen year of High School they gave me an ESL class as an addition to my schedule. After passing ESL exam I could take a language course and I took Spanish for a year and passed it.

Please help me, I have worked so hard to get a chance to go to FIT and now all of my hard work will mean nothing. Tell me who should I contact to maybe resolve this issue. What additional information I can send to their Admission Office to assure them of my English Proficiency.

P.S.

REASONS WHY I CAN NOT TAKE TOEFL:

  • My family has low income, I got fee waivers for all of my college applications and SAT registration. There is no fee waiver for TOEFL. I am unable to pay the fee.
  • Test date is April 9th and results come in May which Admission Office said will be too late to even consider my application. Even if i find the money, I won't have the results on time.

Call FIT admissions (after all, they WANT to admit you if you’re qualified) They’re likely not going to kill your app over something that you can prove achievement over. If you don’t get anywhere, have your GC call on your behalf.

I suppose it wouldn’t really help your case to point out that the sentence should read “Students who have completed FEWER than four years of English” but I’d be awfully tempted.

Just harass them with phone calls and such until they agree to let the TOEFL thing go.

The statement as it appears on FIT’s site seems to mean exactly what you think it means. It sounds like you need to talk to someone other than the person you have already talked to and writie a formal letter to admisisons explaing your situation like you have here and pointing to the webpage and section you cite and ask that the Toefl requirement be removed.

Meanwhile, be aware that Toefl does have a fee waiver process but I do not know whether you would qualify, see https://www.ets.org/s/toefl/pdf/toefl_fee_reduction_service_guidelines.pdf.

Finally, I am wondering whether you can actually be applying to FIT with an expectation of attending if admitted. It is a SUNY public university which offers no need-based financial aid to international students and thus if your family cannot afford the cost of a Toefl test, I am wondering how you intend to pay for college if you are an international applicant. Note, if you are in fact a US citizen or permanent resident and applied as such, then probably the Toefl requjirement should not apply to you at all at FIT.

All you can do is to contact the admissions office at FIT, and ask whether or not you do need to provide a score from an Engish proficiency exam, given that you completed you exited ESL at the end of 9th grade and have been in on-level English classes since then. Ask if they can accept any other evidence of your proficiency (ACT/SAT verbal scores, copy of your ESL exit exam results, Michigan or other proficiency exam that the ESL staff at your HS could administer, etc.) or if the exam must be TOEFL or IELTS.

If FIT wants to be certain that you have strong listening and speaking skills as well as reading and writing skills, it may be necessary for you to take the TOEFL. Do remember that if you don’t get in this year because of the TOEFL score, you can take a gap year while you prepare for and take that exam, then apply for fall 2017.