None of this surprises me. My D applied to a master’s program there that offered her 100% scholarship (she was a strong applicant and they knew they’d be competing with higher ranked programs). Even though there was less than a 5% chance she’d take it, I insisted we visit before turning it down. Everything you said strikes me as 100% accurate, and if anything you may be going soft on some of them.
On the sports piece, it’s worth noting that WF is almost always going to bring up the rear in the ACC in sports other than basketball. Football is always going to be one of the very bottom programs in the conference.
But it is a school that will feel very southern for those from north of the Mason-Dixon line. I think the analogy to SMU is a good one too for a variety of reasons, particularly as it relates to the type of students and backgrounds you’ll find there, but I believe (w/o checking) that WF is a harder admit hurdle. Very fine schools, but there will be many kids there who applied to schools a little further up the ranking pecking order that didn’t make it into them and whose parents can pay.
Worth noting, though, that WF is going to represent you as well as any school in their geographical sphere of influence. I think it’s a strong brand.
FWIW, I found the campus and environs charming, even though D had a definite “no” reaction almost from the beginning. I’ve spent more time in the south and I know what the south offers and appreciate what that is. For a kid who grew up in the PNW, the northeast is a much more comfortable place to be than the southern US, although none of my kids are politically strident people (though tend to lean left). Some of it honestly is the weather.
One thing about Wake that’s worth mentioning is that, along with Bowdoin, they are one of the original TO schools and thus have played a vanguard role there. It’s kind of a progressive element of who they are, and when you read their application material that addresses essays and TO, it makes for an impression of an institution that isn’t as conservative as they might appear.
IDK. As for me, I know I would not have had a problem going to school there. But for my kid, she clearly preferred other environs (ie, New England).