I had no desire to have Christmas dishes, but my mother-in-law decided I needed them. Honestly, I believe her insistence was because she didn’t want to have to “think” about what to get us for Christmas. So, for several years we received either a place setting or serving piece of it. Since my sister-in-law also wanted to be able to give us this as Christmas gifts (again, no need to put any thought into a gift), I had to dial back on what I would have chosen since she didn’t have the means that mil had. Which made me like it even less because not only did I not really want it, but also I had to choose a less expensive option. Eventually I gave it all away.
Later, mil decided I needed those Dept 56 Christmas village houses. I might have felt differently about both the Christmas dishes and the Christmas village had they been something I wanted. I probably sound like an ingrate. I, myself, am not a great gift-giver. It isn’t my love language, and I think that makes me less skilled on the giving end as well. Nevertheless, when I do buy gifts I try to put some effort into thinking about what the recipient would truly like rather than coming up with some “easy button” gift I can put on repeat for several years. Eventually, we talked mother-in-law out of all gift exchanges between us, but it took a long time.