<p>Excellent post, dadtimesthree. Welcome to the board.</p>
<p>Echoing Dadtimesthree's comment: The top journalism schools are going to give you some important advantages that you will not get from a non-journalism school, no matter how good the student newspaper.</p>
<p>First, as Dadtimesthree points out, you'll need EVERY advantage possible to break into that first newspaper job. The best J-schools tend to have strong and large networks of alumni actually working in journalism as well as better leads on entry level journalism jobs. Sure, there are people who graduated from Harvard or Yale or Vassar working in journalism, but numbers-wise, graduates of the top j-schools rule the journalism world. </p>
<p>But a great placement service or alumni network alone won't get you your first job. What will get you your first job is the ability to prove you already have the professional skills in hand to jump in and do the job. </p>
<p>Working on a student newspaper - no matter how good it may be - simply isn't the same as being able to show a prospective employer a transcript full of classes in reporting, interviewing, writing, and editing. </p>
<p>Working on a student newspaper- no matter how good it may be - also isn't the same as being able to show a prospective employer a portfolio full of clips from a REAL professional (read: non-student) newspaper. </p>
<p>Now, it may indeed be possible to get those clips as a student at a non-j-school IF your school has the same type of internship network as the top j-schools do. But, in most cases, journalism internship opportunities tend to be placed at the best j-schools, not at the more generalized schools. Additionally, competition for the best journalism internships is usually pretty intense...and j-school students often have an advantage when it comes to landing these sorts of internships.</p>
<p>Again, I want to stress that it is entirely possible to go to a school without a journalism program and end up working in the field. It's just that, in my opinion at least, it is much harder to get your foot in that proverbial front door than it is if you graduated from a strong journalism school. Of course, it's always possible to go to journalism graduate school. :)</p>