Which college professor would you choose?

Student Lounge College Life
1

<p>These are feedbacks written by students from two different teachers and I'm debating which teacher to take for this writing course. Which teacher did a better job teaching? (course: Intermediate Writing for college fresh) based on their feedback (grammar, word choice, style) and their statement? Which teacher would you choose?</p>

<p>T#1:
Great teacher! She has students write on divisive topics, and really pushes you to succeed. Her comments and feedback strongly improved my writing, too. I highly recommend you take her class if you get the chance. You won't regret it. And as George Zimmer says, "I guarantee it."
Report this rating</p>

<p>Great teacher! She's really passionate about improving her student's writing skills. I was absolutely dreading this writing class, but I grew to really love it. She assigns a lot of essays, almost weekly, but they're definitely possible. Great teacher, recommended her to a lot of friends!</p>

<p>T#2:
Great guy but he is a very tough grader. The kind of teacher who is looking for specific things. I went to the writing center about 5 times for my first paper and obsessed over the details, and in the end I got a 137 out of 150. Other than that he knows his stuff, you just need to go in with the attitude that you will learn from HIM.</p>

<p>I would definitely recommend taking this writing course with Nicholas. He did seem like a tough grader at first, but that only motivated me to put more effort into my papers. Overall, I was pleased with how he taught this course.</p>

2

<p>T#1</p>

3

<p>T#1, no doubt. </p>

4

<p>T#1 definitely.</p>

5

<p>I had a teacher exactly like #2 last semester. He was totally set in his thinking, and not at all open to the perspectives of others. I would avoid a teacher like that again like the plague. He tanked my otherwise stellar, from all my other teachers, gpa.</p>

6

<p>T#1. Tailoring to a really picky professor (which is what #2 sounds like) is doable if necessary, but not worth the added stress if you can avoid it.</p>