2008 College Safety Results - Reader's Digest

<p>Is Your College Student Safe at School?</p>

<p>Almost a year after the Virginia Tech shooting, colleges are getting smarter about campus risks. RD gives out grades and tells parents what to study up on.</p>

<p>Just before midnight, six University of Cincinnati students were watching TV in an on-campus apartment when three men burst through the door. While one of the intruders pointed a gun at the group, the other two scooped up $4,400 worth of laptops, cell phones, video games and cash. Once they had what they wanted, the trio fled into the night.</p>

<p>Furious, the students chased down and tackled one of the burglars -- the one with the gun. In the struggle, it went off, and a bullet grazed a student's leg. His friends piled on the gunman and held him until police showed up.</p>

<p>By the next day, the injured young man was back in his apartment, and the suspect was in jail, charged with burglary, felonious assault and receiving stolen property. But how did the men manage to storm into an on-campus residence that November night in the first place? Simple: Students told police the building's main doors hadn't latched properly for days.</p>

<p>As parents confront ballooning college costs and shrinking acceptance rates, they are finding themselves with an even bigger, more basic problem: Which campuses are safe? Colleges seem like idyllic and secure places, and for the most part, they are. But ivy-covered walls can't keep out every bad element. This country's 6,000 colleges and universities report some 40,000 burglaries, 3,700 forcible sex offenses, 7,000 aggravated assaults and 48 murders a year. Other hazards -- fires, binge-drinking, mental-health problems -- are also on the rise.</p>

<p>Of course, that's not what parents and students see on America's serene campuses. There's a false sense of security, says Harry Nolan, a safety consultant in New York City. "Students see guards patrolling at night or a video camera monitoring the dorm entrance and think, Nothing bad can happen to me," he explains. "People don't know that safety controls are often very lax."</p>

<p>The idea that a bucolic university environment can be a danger zone hit home at Virginia Tech last April, when a deranged senior opened fire on the school's Blacksburg campus, killing 32 and injuring many more before killing himself. The massacre was an extreme example of the threats that can lurk on campus, but it focused attention on the new risks students face -- and on what schools are doing to limit those threats.</p>

<p>Student Criminals
Students typically feel safe around peers, but 80 percent of all crimes on campus are committed by other students. Alison Kiss, program director for Security on Campus, Inc., an advocacy group in King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, says the first six weeks of college require special vigilance. Kiss refers to this period as the red zone and says that's when her group sees a 30 percent spike in calls from student victims: "It's when incoming freshmen are most vulnerable to alcohol abuse, hazing and crimes like acquaintance rape. It's the most dangerous period of a student's campus life."</p>

<p>Of course, dangerous events occur long after the red zone ends. Take the case of Eastern Michigan University senior Laura Dickinson, found dead in her dorm room on December 15, 2006. From the start, local police considered Dickinson's death suspicious. One reason: When they found her half-naked body, there was a pillow covering her face. The school's response, as posted on its website the next morning: "We are fully confident of the safety and security of our campus environment."</p>

<p>For weeks, university officials told students and Dickinson's parents there was no foul play. (The medical examiner later ruled the cause of death was probably asphyxiation.) It wasn't until two months later, when police arrested another student, 20-year-old Orange Taylor III, and charged him with the murder that the stonewalling stopped.</p>

<p>A security camera captured this sequence: Dickinson, holding a white bag, entering the dorm at about 11 p.m. on December 12; Taylor trying repeatedly to get into the locked dorm about five hours later, then slipping in behind another student with a key card; finally, Taylor exiting 90 minutes later, a white bag under his sweatshirt. With his DNA allegedly found on the victim's body, Taylor was charged with murder and sexual assault. He pleaded not guilty. His first trial ended with a hung jury; a new trial date hasn't been set yet. An investigation found that by not promptly dealing with and reporting Dickinson's death as a crime, the university had violated a 1990 federal law known as the Jeanne Clery Act. Named for a Lehigh University student raped and killed in her dorm room, the law requires colleges to report campus crimes to the federal Office of Postsecondary Education in a timely fashion and notify students of threats. In the wake of the probe, three Eastern Michigan administrators, including the university's president, were ousted. The school agreed to pay the Dickinson family $2.5 million and launched new safety policies.</p>

<p>Best Practices: Last September, a St. John's University freshman donned a Fred Flintstone mask and walked onto the New York campus carrying a loaded rifle in a plastic bag. A security guard spotted the end of the barrel and then helped subdue the gunman before shots were fired. As police swarmed the area, panicked students holed up in classrooms. Within eight minutes, they got a text message on their cell phones telling them that an armed man had been arrested on campus and that they should stay put. Messages kept coming for the next three hours while police scoured the campus.</p>

<p>It was the first use of an emergency notification system the school had activated a month earlier. St. John's also has six plasma-screen "e-boards" placed in strategic spots to flash warnings. Says Assistant Vice President Dominic Scianna, "In the world we live in, you just can't be too careful."</p>

<p>To a burglar, a dorm can look like a treasure trove. After all, the typical student is likely to have between $5,000 and $10,000 worth of electronic gear stashed in his or her room. And, as both the University of Cincinnati and Eastern Michigan examples show, gaining access to a dorm isn't as difficult as one might think.</p>

<p>"When I do college inspections," says Robert Siciliano, a Boston-based college-security consultant, "I often find fifty percent of windows in first- and second-floor dorm rooms unlocked. The front entrance may be guarded by an attendant who checks IDs, but it's likely the back door is propped open with a brick, because kids forget their keys."</p>

<p>And students aren't necessarily any more mindful when they're out and about, hustling between dorms, classes and parties, especially at night. Anthony Dariano, a 22-year-old **San Jos</p>

<p>Thanks so much for posting this. We’ll be doing campus visits this coming weekend and it gives us a chance to ask some very important questions.</p>

<p>Maybe it is me but, if Columbia is 21 how come Barnard is 31?</p>

<p>Interesting. But if I remember correctly, Johns Hopkins (#1) requires freshman & sophomores to live on campus. Juniors & Seniors generally live off campus. So they’re doing a spectacular job… for about half the student body.</p>

<p>What does it mean if your child’s school isn’t on the list at all?</p>

<p>After doing a little bit of research, Johns Hopkins provides campus security services for the 1-mile radius around campus in addition to the campus itself so that’s good to know. </p>

<p>I commend all the schools at the top of this list for being proactive in their efforts to keep students safe and happy.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>The ranking was done by comparing the different safety measures each school has or doesn’t have, like self-locking doors or dorms with cameras etc… </p>

<p>If you click on the link that was posted you can see why Columbia and Barnard have different rankings</p>

<p>Thanks a lot for posting this!</p>

<p>“In the world we live in, you just can’t be too careful.”</p>

<p>I don’t agree with this…this article feeds into a hysteria about safety that makes students avoid perfectly safe schools just because they are located in a city, or because a rare incident has occurred there.</p>

<p>JHU provides security for everyone within a one mile radius around the campus. The school really does do a spectacular job, and is always on top of things. While nothing is perfect, jhu does make a true effort, and seems to be quite successful.</p>

<p>There seems to be a lot of schools missing from the list. Where are most of the ivies? Did they get a rank for safety, and I am missing them?</p>

<p>the only problem i can see is too much reliance on technology and not enough of street smarts.
i had a friend who worked for a firm that specialized in safety equipment. the building was surrounded by tall fence. security cameras everywhere. security guards available. despite all that equipment and personnel that person was murdered.
these ratings are nothing more than that.
one is never safe when one thinks one is. letting the guard down is deadly.</p>

<p>Interesting article, but I do agree that no amount of campus vigilance/technology can (or should be expected to) fully replace personal awareness. </p>

<p>Students shouldn’t be made to fear their environments, but they also shouldn’t allow themselves to feel invulnerable, as many do. Self-locking doors are useless if students prop them open with bricks, and a security guard can’t keep out the dorm thief who lives in the dorm. Common sense won’t/can’t protect students from all risks, but it still needs to be exercised. This means keeping your room locked when you leave for any length of time, keeping it locked always if it opens to the outside, calling a campus escort service or walking in a group if you’re going somewhere at an odd hour, etc.</p>

<p>If I use my imagination, I can think of plenty of ways that I could have been a victim of campus crime. I didn’t go crazy devising security strategies (not even close), but I did try to stay decently conscious. I went to a school that was known for being quite safe, but stuff still happened. Stuff always happens. Despite that, I knew kids who would leave their suites (which were open to the outside, on an open campus, a block from a main road, not terribly far from some sketchy areas of town) unlocked, even while they were out or asleep. Most of the people who practiced this sort of carelessness came through college with no security problems, but I also know of one guy who had his car keys stolen from his living room (and, unsurprisingly, his car stolen from the parking lot), and another who woke up to find a homeless man in her common area. Why invite crime?</p>

<p>I think that campus security is incredibly important, and it’s great to see the new technology, the administrative awareness, and so forth. But this should all be supplemental to students’ own common sense.</p>

<p>Even at a school that’s statistically safe, puts a lot of precautions in place, and cautions students about the possibility of crime, there often persists a “nothing bad can happen here” feeling amongst the students. I don’t know what can be done to counteract this persistence (in my experience, we tended to up our personal awareness on an “as needed” basis, rather than take preventative measures), but it is something to be aware of as you prepare to send your kids off to school.</p>

<p>If the ranking is done by security measures taken, I’m surprised my college, the University of Chicago, isn’t on the list. </p>

<ul>
<li><p>They’ve had disaster plans in place since before September 11th, re-evaluated after 9/11, and when they re-evaluated after the VT shootings they determined no changes had to be made. There is an alert system in place that contacts students by email, phone, or text when there is an emergency or important safety notification. </p></li>
<li><p>The campus has the 2nd largest private police force in the world, with 140 professional police officers who patrol an area stretching 25 blocks north-south and about 18-20 blocks west-east. The entire area is also patrolled by Chicago Police. </p></li>
<li><p>You need to swipe your key to enter any dorm and then show your campus ID to the desk attendant (which is staffed 24/7) before swiping several more times before entering your room. Students can only enter the dorm they live in; if I want to visit a friend’s dorm, I need to be signed-in and -out, and my campus ID will be checked. You can’t enter through any backdoors as the article suggests. </p></li>
<li><p>There are of course blue light phones and umbrella services by the police. There is a late night shuttle service you can call for pick-up as well as shuttles that run on four different routes during the night. </p></li>
<li><p>Dorms are separated into Houses, and each house has adult Resident Heads who get to know their residents quite well. The RHs will help students who are struggling emotionally and point them toward the proper resources, take students to the ER who are ill or injured, etc. RHs keep their eyes open for students who are acting differently or strangely, and they’re close enough with residents that roommates or friends would feel comfortable approaching them for help. I know a student taken to the psychiatric hospital by housing staff after odd behavior and countless students who have been advised to seek counseling, including counseling for alcoholism or addiction. There is no stigma attached to our campus mental health services. The school the article highlights says that students can get a same-day 20 minute phone call at the counseling center. At my college, any student who feels they need it can walk into the counseling center and be seen immediately for a full appointment or longer (at least 1 hour) by the therapist on call. The student could also be seen by one of the psychiatrists if necessary. If it’s outside of business hours, there is someone on call. The U of C has a mental health professional for every ~600 people, including students, graduate students, and professors (that was me counting up the list of professionals on the counseling services website and dividing by the number of students). The school they hold up as the ideal has one for every 800 students, not including professors or anyone else. </p></li>
</ul>

<p>Anyway, I looked at the full rankings, and the U of C isn’t listed anywhere in the top-145. I doubt there are cameras in parking lots (almost nobody drives anyway), and I doubt there are cameras in dorms. That seems a little strange to me anyway, especially since there’s 24 hour staff. I’m just surprised. I realize the U of C campus isn’t the safest, and it’s certainly not in the safest area, but the school has made tremendous advances and has taken many steps to ensure students are kept as safe as reasonably possible.</p>