<p>I would have also been put off, I admit—a lack of largesse is always a flaw. However, two stories, lesson obvious re letting one person stop you from embracing an entire city and Vanderbilt is really a city unto itself…with 6000 undergrads yes, but also 6000 grad students, a regional lead hospital, and tons of contributions in its region of the USA, …I think it is the second or third biggest employer in TN. I also try not to judge say Paris on the rudeness and lack of largesse of a hotel concierge. </p>
<p>yes, I compared Nashville to Paris but then I just had a glass of wine.</p>
<p>OK…
Duke admit son, 2005. Denied at his Ivy league crush and admitted to some very good match colleges, son never anticipated admission to Duke and had no attachment to it whatsoever because he expected a waitlist or rejection. Goes to overnight on a Blue Devil Day, and no one comes to get him. He is the last student waiting as darkness falls. Finally a very very odd person who cannot make eye contact, clearly has limitations of some kind that might be handicap level, comes to get him. Tells him that he was called and made to come get a Prospie as a “joke for his fraternity.” Then leaves son in Duke dorm without a key and says he may return by 3am or so. Nice, Huh?<br>
Duke son wanders with boys in tuxedos to what turned out to be the final Duke Sympnony Orchestra performance, chats some of them up. Watches senior Dukies give their final goodbye speeches to their beloved conductor and sees a real espirit de corps. and he realizes that the rude guy isn’t Duke.<br>
Spends four of the happiest years of his life at Duke, with a seat in the symphony where he maintained many friends, held offices and also loved his conductor.<br>
Duke son also competes on written exams and through three elimination rounds based on social skills with literally hundreds of students and is chosen to be in an elite group that gives tours for major events, conferences and events at Duke. He is in a position to make people welcome.</p>
<p>Vandy son attends Accepted Student Day and has a merit scholarship. Very anxious and negative re the Greek scene reputation. Student panel is sadly four Greeks with two boys in Identical pink and blue shirts (diff frats though!) with the same logos on them and no independent student speaking about the other half of the college socially. The one girl he feels will address life for non Greeks opines that her sorority has made all the difference in her life at Vandy. I hear a segment of parents and students looking for their car keys. Tours are offered and 10 new guides show up. Son notices a girl in a Red Coat giving a tour and we follow him to her. She is independent, a film major and moving to Sweden soon. She shows him her dorm, takes him to lunch, her BF joins them and son realizes…hey out of 6000, I would be a fool to stereotype everyone.<br>
Three years later son is in a European country for a semester. Girl in Red Coat and her BF, now ages 25…invite him for a weekend in Sweden. He gets on a plane and goes. </p>
<p>Lesson from my experience…follow through with April visits. Let your son or daughter figure it out and everyone hold your horses re jumping to conclusions. </p>
<p>With 28,300 applications…it is a sure bet that Vanderbilt has 1600 really great young men and women who will deposit and move into the Commons. Perhaps Vandy will be your child’s best ever decision. Perhaps the dice will fall and another great community will be his or her next home. But don’t make random decisions.</p>