ACT Writing Scorers Are Making MAJOR ERRORS

@quietdesperation If this was about an individual’s dissatisfaction with his or her writing score, your comment might hold weight. Unfortunately, this is about a standardized testing organization’s BROKEN system.

How much money in merit scholarships do you think students around the world have lost out on because ACT’s scoring errors? All of the other sections are scored electronically, which takes any subjectivity out of the equation–but the writing scores are supposedly graded by living, breathing, humans. That means “trained readers” must must be sticking to a reliable, consistent formula for scoring writing tests, right?

Funny thing. Everyone who has ever worked at ACT seems to bemoan the organization’s “lack of training.”

                                                                            ~*~ 

Here are some reviews posted on Indeed.com and GlassDoor.com by lovely ACT employees who have spent anywhere from several years to over a decade working at ACT’s Iowa City headquarters.

“Bloated management that doesn’t really care about your work, frequent technical issues, often unable to help customers. Low company morale.”

“Many of the employees showed up late and were very unprofessional, and there were things going on inside the company that broke rules as well as laws.”

"All of the workers know that you do not learn anything in training. In my case, I didn’t either. Training doesn’t prepare you for a regular day at work…

“Utterly dysfunctional leadership…nonprofit mission losing out to corporate mindset.”

“The working environment is a joke…Additional conflicts were created by the 3rd party data host - no one within ACT is capable of assisting with resolving issues created by this data host. Ultimately, you are being told you are the Primavera application owner but in reality have zero ownership powers…Any sort of attempts to deal with this groups’ deficiencies are met with hostility, even when done in private and in a professional manner.”

“Chaotic and bad management…They hire nothing but druggies and promote individuals to supervisors who have no clue as to what they are doing.”

“Boredom sets in after the first two days. Co-workers are inherently lazy and slow. It was not uncommon for several of them to not show up and the supervisors casually worked around that.”

“The hardest part of the job was being cross trained and being switched departments at any time of the day. Sometimes projects were long and tedious even pointless or not accurate due to times and dates.”

“Minimum wage is what you get, and for what you have to do, it is not worth the pay. Its the saying you give what you get and I didn’t push myself much because I didn’t feel it was worth it.”

“There is lack in communication within the whole company…Even with a college degree, they were barely paying me enough to survive. I had to even rely on other government support because my income at ACT was not enough.”

“Management is not supportive or service oriented, they care more about revenues and selling (or they call it “recommendation”), you can miss many days and be late just as long as your selling track record is in the top spot. If you do not make sales, they start giving you problems and are always on you. If a customer requests a supervisor, they will not come until you have tried everything and then maybe they will come but other than that, they completely ignore you.Co-workers are okay but they lie sometimes to get sales and management will not say anything to them.”

“ACT is a small company that got too big too fast. They weren’t ready for the extra work and staff and were forced to downsize areas that were consolidated, choosing to let full time employees go…”

AND MY PERSONAL FAVORITE:

“At first, I thought ACT was an awesome company to work for but then I learned how selfish executives were…There was never consistency throughout…this company sweeps corrupted information under the rug.”

Many of the comments also focus on the below-average compensation extended to employees and pressure placed on staff to sell, sell, sell more tests to kids. Did I mention another reviewer posted about “work-from-home options” being available to potential employees? Yeah, that’s really comforting. Your writing test could have been scored by an emotional chick in her 30s kicked back on the couch watching The United States of Tara and chugging boxed wine while sobbing over her boyfriend’s infidelity. There’s accuracy for you.

Yes, there is definitely something major to pursue here. I will keep you guys updated on what transpires.

@devram2000 No, I specifically incorporated the words “in accordance with Perspective One/Two/Three” to introduce my discussion of the various viewpoints. I studied the examples provided on ACT’s website and followed the prompt to a tee, as I did during the September 2015 test when the new writing format was first introduced.

@shastad2 That is VERY interesting. Her clients’ results could very well establish a pattern of inconsistency amongst ACT’s employees and their new scoring criteria.

I think the OP should continue pushing the ACT corporation. We cannot live in world without recourse. I would certainly involve my GC, the school, news media, etc… Its ridiculous that they can’t even do a simple check to make sure that the writing sample is matched to the correct name. It should not need a 3 month hand score time frame.

Just so everyone is aware, this is the writing scoring summary. With the OP getting a 9, it means she got the minimum score for each section… which is unlikely, IMHO.

New ACT Writing Scores
(Beginning in the September 2015 Test Events)

Subject-Level Writing Score 1–36
Individual Domain Scores:

Ideas and Analysis 2–12
Development and Support 2–12
Organization 2–12
Language Use and Conventions 2–12

@niflheim000 Can your school request a copy of the essay? See this quick link I found:

https://www.act.org/essayview/

@niflheim000 Also found this:

How can ACT writing test results be used?

Writing test results provide colleges with additional information that can be used to make college admissions and course placement decisions. The writing and reading test scores complement scores from the ACT English test. The high school and colleges to which a student has ACT report writing scores can also view an image of the essay.

So, colleges can get a copy of your writing. This would be a way for you to prove that its yours and have it looked at by an independent party. If colleges can get it, your GC should be able to get it. I would pursue that - ASAP!

@Niflheim The same thing happened to me! I got a 32 Composite with only a 21 Essay! All my practice test essays—graded by a tutoring company—have been around a 33 consistently, so I don’t think they graded it too easily. I also got a 36 on my English section. Should I request a regrade for my essay? Thanks!

@niflheim000 The same thing happened to me! I got a 32 Composite with only a 21 Essay! All my practice test essays—graded by a tutoring company—have been around a 33 consistently, which tells me that different graders were consistent. I also got a 36 on my English section, which doesn’t really correlate to my 21 Essay. Should I request a regrade for my essay? Thanks!

I got a 33 Composite and a 26 Essay! I have been getting at least 30s on my practice essays.

I had the exact same problem! 33 composite with a shocking 22! At first I thought it might have been my handwriting, but the score just doesn’t match with my SAT score or ability. I emailed the ACT through the website.

We need to collectively complain to the ACT these mistakes are unacceptable. I am not willing to pay $50 in order for them to review my writing score by the time college admissions come out. Everyone, make sure you email the act and speak to your guidance counselors.

@niflheim000 , do you have proof of a systemic problem? Yes, I’m sure your score is in error and you have a handful of people on cc questioning their scores in the mid low to mid 20s. How many people take the act each sitting? Let’s use 200k as an estimate. Do you think it’s reasonable that no errors will occur over the course of grading 200k tests? Do banks make errors? brokerages? doctors? accountants? are those professional organizations?

Personally, I think you should count yourself lucky that you have your scores. The act states scores for the december test will be released December 22, 2015 – February 5, 2016. Would colleges accept your act score the 2nd week of feb? You should have planned for oct to be your last test date.

My suggestion is to send the 35 composite and one of your other test scores with a high essay score. Send a note to your adcoms that given your overall results and your essay score on the first test, you believe there was a clerical error, you’ve asked the act to take a look and you’ll be in touch with the corrected score.

good luck to you!

@Marywontlose Agreed. It’s incomprehensible that students are forced to foot the bill for the ACT’s erroneous actions. Regardless of whether you elect to pay the $50, there is a 3-month wait for the secondary review of a writing booklet. By the time they admit to their mistake, admissions decisions will be posted on the portals, and kids will collectively have paid heaps of money for an arguably moot point. If they are scoring essays incorrectly, and the problem is not about individuals, but instead the overall system, who’s to say the issue won’t repeat itself? I definitely don’t trust ACT to perform reliably now that so many people have come forward bringing their inconsistent scores to light. What we have to do is get to the root of the problem: are test scores being mixed up, is a lack of uniform training for employees to blame, or is there a much larger issue within the ACT’s organizational structure? It seems to me that this is the WORST time of year for them to test out a new format for writing. They should have anticipated problems and worked to rectify them, or at least be willing to admit to their mistakes now that they’ve been made apparent. ACT needs to be held responsible and accountable for the loss of merit scholarships, admission offers, monetary costs for rescoring, and stress and anxiety they’ve caused their clients. Because, yes, we are their CLIENTS, and regardless of whether or not they insist on keeping up the pretense of operating as a nonprofit, students PAY them to perform a service, and if they fail to deliver, they are subject to legal repercussions. I do intend to try to seek representation to bring ACT’s reputation as a nonprofit standardized test provider into question. With the compensatory damages that would be awarded in a case like this, legal professionals would be pushing each other out of the way to represent the plaintiffs.

@suzyQ7 Thank you so much for posting the link to the Essay Viewer! I’ve gotten in touch with my guidance counselor, and she said our school does not utilize the service; however, she is more than willing to register for an account. This is an indispensable tool we can use to print our essays (whether they ARE our own or they’re someone else’s mixed up with ours) and save them to our laptops to keep a copy for our records!!! The rubrics used to grade our essays should also be accessible in Essay Viewer.

@bigboy12 @Salutation If your tutoring companies had access to the new scoring guides released by ACT ahead September 2015 test, and you are ABSOLUTELY certain you prepared for the new perimeters established for this fall, then I would be suspicious. It’s one thing if you were having an off day, but it’s another thing entirely if the employees ACT claims are “trained readers” are just circling random places on the rubrics because they’re peeved about the sexist quid pro quo going on in the workplace (OH YES, I found TONS of claims about this from current and past employees!!) and their working environment is so hostile that are unable or unwilling to perform their job duties.

@quietdesperation I understand and appreciate the points that you’re trying to convey. Sometimes doctors, brokerages, banks, and accountants DO make errors. However, whether they’re “sorry” or not hardly matters when there are dead people, homeless people, broke people, and robbed people who are all victims of the aforementioned. All of these professionals must legally face up to their mistakes and pay the price; if ACT wants to receive government subsidized benefits as a nonprofit organization serving the public, then they will, too.

Thank you for your advice! I do appreciate it, and I think what you’re saying is very reasonable. However, I still intend on pursuing the matter to the best of my ability.

I’m going into dangerous waters here.

I hate to be that guy, but all the people with composite 30+ complaining that their essays were only in the 20s need to stop pointing fingers at ACT and realize that–unlike MC sections–essay scores can fluctuate wildly due to one’s familiarity with the prompt. I feel like a lot of people are upset, and rightfully so, that their score is lower than desired, but your writing ability extends far beyond this lone essay score. Because of this, it’s easy to look at someone like @niflheim000 whose score is clearly incorrect and wonder if the same has happened to you. There’s a 99% chance that this isn’t the case,and that you just didn’t write your best essay. Don’t take it so hard. Colleges care more about the essays you write for them anyway, so just nail those and forget about it. If you’re still mad and can retake, do so. However, don’t take out your frustration on ACT, it’s probably not their fault.

Best of luck OP, but everyone else needs to grow up a little and move on. It’s not the end of the world.

The good news is colleges have never paid much attention to the writing score, and now they will pay even less attention to it.

My guess is that the problem is not with the essay graders, but with the rubric system that the ACT designed for scoring the essays. It is quite possible that the rubric was poorly designed, and it is fairly obvious that at the very least it was not communicated well to test takers. But attacking the essay graders and making hyperbolic complaints doesn’t really advance your cause. It is quite likely that the graders are grading the essays exactly the way the ACT wanted them graded, and that is what you should be focusing on.

35 Composite
36 English, 36 Reading
22 Writing

I abhor bragging, and only included the above scores for context.
To be succint: In school, I am a capable writer.

Could writing scores be messed up?

I was surprisingly not a victim of the new ACT writing (32C, 31W). I would like to add that what’s also weird is that the curve for the writing section changes for each administration. So, 11/11/11/11 may be a 31 on one test (like the September one) and a 34 on a different test (the 2015-2016 Official Practice Test). It seems odd that there isn’t a uniform curve for the writing section. How is one prompt harder than another prompt?

Did everyone here get back there December writing ACT score? I didn’t.

@saadzmirza A 22 is equivalent to 8 on the old scale, which is by no means bad. When I did the old scale essay I received an 8, despite a 5 in AP Comp and a much better essay later. You’re fine.

When you go beyond criticizing the test and the system to mocking imaginary employees, you need to take a step back and calm the heck down.