<p>Pretty funny topic that's been debated since the late 19th century, I reckon...</p>
<p>I'm a Lab School /UChicago grad who also went to grad school at Columbia and believe me, there's no comparison between these two schools. Chicago is an intellectual hotbed where cleverness, insight and erudition are demanded from students and teachers alike. The quest for knowledge and personal intellectual growth are the pillars on which the Chicago culture is built.</p>
<p>Columbia, although a perfectly good school, reminded me of a large cafeteria where indifferent students stand in line to get their weekly dole of soup and crackers. There is an astounding lack of intellectual discourse at Columbia that stunned me when I got there. The undergrads show up for their classes, do their assignments with a minimum amount of fuss and interaction with profs. and then stealthily graduate after 4 years. It reminded me more of a large, wealthy public high school than a community of scholars. The school was a tremendous disappointment, to say the least.</p>
<p>On a related note, my father, a former professor at Cornell University, told me when I was applying to schools that the grad students and professors that impressed him the most during his career were from Chicago. With Harvard and Yale, he said, you never knew what you were going to get. Some were very bright, some were rather dim. In contrast, the people that left lasting impressions on him were, bye and large, from Chicago. </p>
<p>As I've gotten older, I've also come to appreciate my Chicago degree more and more. A degree from Harvard, for instance, acts as a sort of crimson albatross about one's neck; telling people that you went to Harvard is a bit like announcing that you own a $250,000 Enzo Ferrari. Its a bit tasteless and embarrassing and most people will think that you're an ass.</p>
<p>Telling people that you went to UChicago has quite the opposite effect. A Chicago degree is rare, it marks you as an intellectual heavyweight (even if you're not :)), it elicits immediate respect from people who are informed enough to know, and you automatically have a psychological advantage in any debate with someone who had the misfortune of attending a school other than Chicago :) </p>
<p>So, in conclusion, no, UChicago is most definitely not an Ivy League school. Heaven forbid that we ever travel down THAT path.</p>