AP Spanish vs. School Newspaper

My dilemma is that I cannot take both classes next year. They conflict with each other, so I have to pick one.

If I had to decide between both classes earlier, I would have chosen AP Spanish in a heartbeat. I have an incredibly good relationship with the teacher (I had her for Spanish III as a sophomore). She wrote me a letter of recommendation that I needed to have when I applied for DACA and has helped me tremendously with the process. She adores me a lot - she said it herself - and I’ve been wanting to take AP Spanish since sophomore year, so part of me wants to give up the school newspaper (which is a class rather than an after school activity) to fulfill that desire.

The problem is, however, that I might become editor-in-chief of the school newspaper next year. I am not 100% sure that I will obtain the position, but there is a decent chance that I will. Being editor-in-chief has its obvious perk; I will have an admirable leadership position (one of the only ones I will have next year) to put on my college application. If it’s worth mentioning, I plan on majoring in English in college.

I’m going to be brutally honest - if I don’t become editor-in-chief, then I’ll most likely drop the class and take AP Spanish instead. If I do obtain the position, however, then I will take up the offer and pass on AP Spanish. I’m just afraid that my schedule will no longer be as rigorous if I drop AP Spanish… If I were to drop it, I would still be taking three other APs (the maximum amount you can take at my school without special permission), but I’m also planning on taking some easier classes (Precalculus, Physics, and, if I have to drop AP Spanish, Economics… these are all regular classes, by the way, since my school does not offer honors). I really wanted to take AP Spanish so that I can increase my course rigor, show my strength in the humanities, and complete four years of a foreign language, but editor-in-chief is also something I really want and, dare I say it, need for the sake of having a significant leadership position.

My question is… would colleges penalize me for not having a rigorous enough schedule if I choose the school newspaper over AP Spanish? Or would they praise me for having a leadership position (one college that I really want to go to places strong emphasis on being a leader)?

If it helps, I speak Spanish fluently, so I can easily get a high score on the SAT Subject Test and/or take a placement exam in college if doing so will alleviate the damage from not taking AP Spanish.

Sorry for the INCREDIBLY long post, but this is something that has been bugging me for days! I would be eternally grateful if someone can give me some advice and/or reassurance. Thanks guys!

Okay, can I first say that I think it’s kind of problematic that you would quit newspaper just because you didn’t get editor-in-chief (this is coming from an EIC of another school newspaper)? I don’t think they should pick an editor who would have left just because he or she did not get the “admirable” leadership position.

However, if you don’t enjoy newspaper at all and just want the position for having a position’s sake, I definitely think you should take AP Spanish. But to me, being an editor of a school paper (or just being a top editor or working on staff in general) offers you so much more than taking a language class in a language you are already fluent in (also I’m assuming just for the prestige of the AP label) would.

Rigor is important when colleges evaluate you as an applicant. I wouldn’t personally mold my life to be how top colleges want me to be, but I also think after you hold a certain number of APs, your extra-curriculars and leadership are what will really set you apart.

But again… I feel that if you’re going to be editor next year, you should genuinely love working on the staff and have no concerns that another class would be better. You also shouldn’t be in it for the title; it’s the skills that you acquire working on the newspaper staff and working as a top editor (which I’m assuming you would be even if you weren’t editor-in-chief) that really matter.

Update: I did not get the editor-in-chief position. Now I am legitimately considering quitting the class because I would much prefer maintaining a rigorous schedule than sacrifice it and be a news editor.

I am planning on applying to Wellesley College, which places emphasis on leadership, so if anyone knows if having rigor or news editor position is better, PLEASE let me know! I have to finalize my schedule soon. Thanks guys.