<p>Orangepop, we've just gone through the process of trying to find programs that fit my s's particular interests in this area and I would say there is a difference in terms of what a student would spend the majority of his or her time doing. Here's what we've found to date that may (or, <em>may not</em> : ) be helpful - realize it may be limited in its scope...There seem to be "streams" to follow...: In my son's case, once he visited three programs and sat in on classes, he pretty quickly identified his favorite approach due mostly to his own tendencies (eg. he loves creating music but the technology is his instrument...not the instruments, although he is proficient at a few and can play several. He absolutely wants and needs both the school-of-music foundation and classes in composition...Yet he wants to obtain a deep technical grasp and develop transferable tech skills as a "creator" and "producer" of content for multiple media, including audio but also beyond...). Mind you, the three programs he looked into are all portfolio+interview/audition-based, very competitive, and admit small numbers (eg. U. Mich admits apx. 16). So, we await future decisions to see what he'll ACTUALLY be doing...</p>
<p>At any rate, here's a stab at describing the difference from my non-music, layman's perspective:</p>
<p>Recording engineering at university level with strong school of music option -- possible to achieve at a handful of schools via different avenues (eg. U Mich can be a Performing Arts Tech BFA Curriculum C with engineering concentration OR Curriculum D, BS...the latter is more engineering intense...Indiana Jacobs School of Music, Recording Arts Department, very hands on in terms of recording/sound reinforcement opportunities, is BS degree, however, not as much emphasis on actual composition, especially electronic composition, decided aversion to electroacoustic genre...NYU Clive Davis at Tisch school, emphasis on producing, including recording, with decided music business emphasis while NYU Steinhardt Music Technology is more composition and performance (and digital performance) focused...we did not deeply explore the following due to son's geographic interests, but you may also wish to look into University of Miaimi, USC, Colorado, Northwestern, plus a myriad of tech/engineering options at the primary music schools. In my son's case, he wanted his evaluation to be on his portfolio of created works as opposed to single-instrument performance superiority (guess why : ).</p>
<p>All the programs we visited were phenomenal in their own ways, and are well-regarded. At NYU's Clive Davis, our particular concern was that being part of Tisch school and having a contemporary/pop music feel seemed to separate the program from the (separate) school of music and the western canon. It also seemed challenging to integrate with other specializations such as film (this is true everywhere, as this type of program is in essence, already "specialized honors.")
At Indiana, the opportunities to record live were awesome due to the size of the school of music and the program was very well put together. Our principal concern was that there did not seem to be a required curriculum around electronic composition at this time.
At University of Michigan, my son found his perfect fit in terms of flexibility. The program is actually called Performing Arts Technology and is very customizable to meet/match a student's intended area of concentration. It is part of the School of Music, and as such, has a strong core of theory and musicianship underlying its foundation. There is a BM stream for those who want to pursue performance PLUS develop technology skills; there is a sonic arts stream, a multimedia stream, an engineering stream, etc. Courses include some film, can include digital performance, include math (calculus 1) and computer programming. It's quite a unique combination and definitely worth exploration. And the bonus is that it's at U. Mich, a school my son immediately bonded with.</p>
<p>I can't tell for sure, but based on the way you asked the question, you may wish to explore these programs.
You may also want to do so as early as possible because the portfolio work is unbelievably time-consuming.</p>
<p>Best wishes for a productive search!
Cheers,
K</p>