Does anyone know the weight an art supplement has on admission at UPenn? I am a horn player with strong music extracurriculars, is it recommended I submit a supplement? I am not planning on majoring in music. I would probably submit two different style/era solo pieces or just do a whole Mozart concerto. Would this definitely help my application, or would I risk that they assumed I was a better player based off my ECs?
It may only have effect if you can wow them, exceptionally good. They will have the music professors review it.
Do not worry if it is too good!
The Ivy and other top schools receive a ton of arts supplement materials each admissions cycle. If you deem that your own materials have a good chance of rising above other horn players, submitting the arts supplement is going to help you. All top schools have school orchestra, and they’re always looking for excellent horn players. Keep in mind that many top conservatory level musicians submit their materials, so in general if you’re at that level, you’re good. If you’re just above average in your local area with no state or national distinctions (i.e., section principal, state honor orchestra or national honor orchestra or competition wins beyond local, etc.), I’d pause to rethink about submitting the materials.
I think it helped my daughter to submit art and music supplements, even though she will not be majoring in art or music (and may not even have time to take courses in those areas). It sounds like you are an accomplished player and have devoted a lot of time to your music. You might as well show as well as tell.
Keep in mind what Penn says:
There is an adage - the thicker the file, the thicker the kid. This should not deter you, however. If your work is truly exceptional, submit it. But since 17 year-olds often have an inflated view of what is exceptional, ask your music teacher what s/he thinks of your idea.
Actually, they may have music professors review it. Penn is quite upfront in saying that not all supplements get sent for a faculty review.
A general rule is that your music supplement would have to be outstanding – more or less conservatory level - for it to have any chance to positively impact your application. If your play is not at an extremely high level you would be better off simply noting your music activities and accomplishments in your application.