<p>razorback -</p>
<p>My opinion on the PETER PAN song follows. I apologize for not posting sooner: my own students and I are so busy preparing for their biggest onslaught of college auditions that I spend most of my time doing that. I am only able to post with any regularity right now because I am, WONDERFULLY, still on Christmas break from my grad work :) - but next week, the full grind starts again for me. So unfortunately, I am not able to address many individual song queries - I only respond to those here when the songs in question have very special contexts (such as the PETER PAN song, or the race/ethnicity-specific question which I recently addressed). In those cases, I know that my professional experience will enable me to help quickly, since these questions tend to have answers that are more "yes/no" in the conventional wisdom of the MT industry rather than answers that are simply "opinion" about which songs are "best." Because matching songs to specific students and MT repertoire is my greatest area of expertise, I often have to stop myself from typing responses to song queries when I am itching to do so! :) - but I know it wouldn't be fair to only answer some people's questions of this type and not answer everyone's. So I save most of that info for my own students and help here in a more general way. (I can, however, address specific medical voice questions, since my grad faculty encourages me to do that as part of my training - "community education" is part of what we do.)</p>
<p>As for I'm Flying - although it does sound as if the singer fits the role, it's not a good audition choice unless she is specifically auditioning for that show OR UNLESS she is an extraordinarily sophisticated actress who can PHYSICALIZE the song without CHOREOGRAPHING or DANCING it. Ok - now I'll try to make that clear! :)</p>
<ol>
<li><p>Caution #1 : It is a "one-note" kind of song. In other words, it says to a college, who wants to see the RANGE of what a performer can do, "look, I'm small and could play PETER PAN." It is better to convey this definitely marketable physical and vocal type through a song that is not SO specific, because this songs presents acting limitations that aren't worth the trade-off of using the song to point to tumbling skills on a resume. If that is important to a college, BELIEVE ME, they will SEE IT on a resume or ask about it. A great example which just came up at UMich during SEUSSICAL auditions last night, according to my students there: In the freshman class, they have a PHENOMENAL tumbler - he threw a pass that was something like round-off/2 back handsprings/arabian/punch front - and just kept right on wowing them - but he never did anything to specifically indicate that he could tumble at his audition for UM last year, even though tumbling is SO marketable - it was simply a part of his resume - but oh, the faculty definitely KNEW about his tumbling prowess and were eager to see it last night! </p></li>
<li><p>Caution #2: I'm Flying presents a very specific acting challenge for a young performer. In choosing an audition piece, what the piece conveys about the performer as an actor is just as important as what it conveys about them as a singer. You're right that I'm Flying is fairly challenging vocally - not the most difficult, but it's a good song to show off a strong belt, which is always a plus - BUT it truly is basically ABOUT the act of flying. So in order to act it well, she has to be able to convey the SENSATIONS of actual flying without moving frenetically, without simply extending her arms joyfully all of the time (once or twice is ok, but more than that would be overkill), etc. She could, of course, also create a subtext which makes the song NOT about ACTUAL flying but rather about the analogous feeling one gets when one is euphoric because of new love, great achievement, etc. - but that's where a pretty sophisticated interpretive process would need to take over. (I could see such a thing being done very well by a cabaret artist, for example, perhaps with a more languid tempo.)</p></li>
</ol>
<p>I really thought about this song for a long time - as with most people who are passionate about their jobs, I love a brain challenge! - and it IS an infectious and fun song! I just know that without considering the above factors, especially the acting concerns I detailed in #2, this choice might be in danger of looking silly in comparsion to songs that other female auditionees of this young woman's type may be singing at college auditions.</p>
<p>ALL of that having been said - if this actress is a child (younger than about 14), it's a GREAT, FUN choice - even for a professional audition! The "rules" (HA - there are no "rules" :) - but there is conventional wisdom) are entirely different for children's auditions. Casting directors, especially in NYC, almost always want to see kids who are "REAL" kids and who also fit the type they need - and of course, who have talent. So anything that brings all of this out of a kid works . An 8 year-old student of mine reeeeeeeeally wanted to sing "Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again" for her ANNIE national tour audition last spring - it was her first big audition, and she just loves that song and sings it while rollerblading around her house, playing baseball, etc. :) - so I said "go for it." She went in and lit the place up and got right down to the end - and when they released her (I think probably because she had NO dance training at the time), Martin Charnin came over to her and said, "YOU come back to us!" I think this was a reflection not only of her excellent voice but of her "real kid"-ness coming out in the joy she exuded when singing that song. But that "rule" of "sing whatever" only applies in the professional world until adolescence. By the way, parents, PLEASE don't think little ones all need coaches - although some very young performers have them, this little girl simply happens to be a family friend whose parents asked me to listen to her to make sure she was singing healthily, since she belts and "operas" her head off all the time - they can't stop her! :)</p>
<p>Hope this helps razorback and others - and now I must continue the coaching mania! Good luck to all of you who are also entering your "audition mania" time - and HAVE FUN! :)</p>