I’m deciding between Bates and GW. I like the academic reputation at Bates but I’m concerned that it might be too small and not diverse enough. Meanwhile, I like GW’s location and diversity but I’m concerned about the higher student teacher ratio and the lower academic ranking.
If you could not see yourself being happy or fitting in at Bates then you won’t. Sometimes it is better to go to the school that fits you, that is right for you, than it is to choose a school you dislike because you think it is better respected. And in GW’s defense, it is still an amazing school.
The NESCAC schools are narrower in diversity than larger schools but still they aren’t like they were 50 years ago. This year’s Bates class is from 43 countries and all 50 states and 37% kids of color.
So compare that to other small schools and I think you might feel better.