<p>I kinda said this on this thread page 4 post#52 but now see that lost in Tiger mom- usual Bears’ side tracking </p>
<p>-this reminds me of the time " the nurture assumption " was published.
<a href=“http://www.amazon.com/Nurture-Assump...5018376&sr=1-1[/url]”>http://www.amazon.com/Nurture-Assump...5018376&sr=1-1</a>
It started out with Malcolm Gladwell’s rather nice NYer interview with the author. then cheapo gossip papers / press picked it up dubbing as
"parents do not matter! friends do! "
which, is totally out of context if you read er… some 500 hundred pages of tiny no frill font no pictures research paper-sh book. I bulldozed thru because I was angry at first, then there were aha! moments as I understand culture more, how history of parenting style changed over the decades in western culture and why, let alone how thing are done in other parts of the world flora fauna included (the author is this brain grandma covers all weird stuff from chicklit to detective novel. I had to read dozen or so more books she mentioned to get them half way) and the book became sort of my keystone or, tape measure of my thought ( spying/ disecting) process up to my kid’s pre teen years. - his hormone kicked in, nothing mattered anymore but daily survival, physically, monetary, emotionally, last thing I needed was generic “parenting book”
now what, 15 or so years since first published, her “theory” is somewhat become norm and in the way respected in academia and between common advice givers.</p>
<p>It was 1994, I think. After Penelope what’s her name and Dr.mom etc, advice giving -parenting book had this trait, what’s parents do to kids can up their chance on anything, so moms would hang mobile over cribs, play Mozart and such, do “I” communication, “I feel hurt when you do this and that” " I don’t feel that is fair what you said to your sister, how do you feel if someone said that to you?"
never " you hurt me" " I don’t like you" “you are bad”
Judith Harris was a college child psychology text book writer because she was sickly and couldn’t leave home. She realized that from her own experience and researches, she no longer believed what she was made to write. She published her finding in respected psychology peer journal and gotten rave reviews, then everyone wonder her brilliance yet lack of credentials.
The book was an answer to such interrogation done by hi mighty doctors, profs asked her
" who are you? jobless iron worker or something?"
The publisher offered her book deal was not that respected academic one, yet NYer interview by Malcolm Gladwell put her on the map.
BUT
Judith put Malcolm on the map as well. He was brown away by Judith and started writing about psychology, which eventually culminated in “Tipping Point”
he acknowledged Judith in the book, even named her before his parents!
Then sort of dumped her.
I love Malcolm but will forever remind him because who and why he is the guy he is now… OK, that is VERY biased,
I did write in " ask me" card at Malcolm’s book talk at 92st Y " did Judith Harris really influenced you to write about psychology? What did you do when you are teenage boy in Canada, really nothing but cows? Do you think you are privileged? ( he is)"
He answered last two questions, ignored the first, which I believe because it’s true!!!
don’t worry grandma ( Judith) I will fight for you.</p>
<p>there there Bears’side-track again.
Read it! folks, I mean you are done child-rearing, so read her second book, No Two Alike.</p>