Can you guys grade my essay?

Hey, I am a junior preparing for the SAT and wanted some advice for the SAT Essay. I had recently taken the SAT on April and my lowest score was on writing because of my essay, which was a 9. If you guys could grade my essay and give any advice, it would be great (btw, if you were wondering, I did make up some quotes :P).

Prompt: Think carefully about the issue presented in the following excerpt and the assignment below.

Most human beings spend their lives doing work they hate and work that the world does not need. It is of prime importance that you learn early what you want to do and whether or not the world needs this service. The return from your work must be the satisfaction that work brings you and the world’s need of that work. Income is not money, it is satisfaction; it is creation; it is beauty.

~ Adapted from: W.E.B. Du Bois, The Autobiography of W.E.B. Du Bois: A Soliloquy on Viewing My Life from the Last Decade of Its First Century

Is it more important to do work that one finds fulfilling or work that pays well? Plan and write an essay in which you develop your point of view on this issue. Support your position with reasoning and examples taken from your reading, studies, experience, or observations.

A common adage states, “do what you love, love what you do.” Mahatma Gandhi, a well-known civil rights activist regarded as the father of India, reflected this statement through his humanitarian actions and ideals. Although a well-established lawyer with an education from Britain and experience in South Africa, Gandhi was only able to find satisfaction by fighting for his country’s independence and by aiding those who were less fortunate than himself, such as untouchables, men and women who were treated harshly as they were born into the lowest caste. As shown by Gandhi’s experiences, it is more important for an individual to pursue what he loves rather than what achieves him money. This notion has also been exemplified by historical figures and American literature.

One compelling illustration, which demonstrates how satisfaction from a job is more significant than the wealth attained from it, is portrayed by the novel, Invisible Man, by Ralph Ellison. The main protagonist, an unnamed narrator, must face a multitude of challenges as a black man in a segregated and racist society. Seeking to promote egalitarian ideals where he lives, Harlem, New York, the narrator decides to join an organization called the “Brotherhood” as a well-paid speaker. Later, though, the protagonist realizes that the Brotherhood has manipulated him in order to further it’s duplicitous schemes, which include bringing chaos and anarchy to Harlem. Consequently, the narrator abandons the Brotherhood to pursue his own ideals and beliefs rather than being an “invisible man” whose identity is dependent on the convictions of others. The protagonist follows what he felt would bring him satisfaction rather than upholding his well-paying job with the Brotherhood.

The theme that a job that brings happiness is more important than one that pays well is also exemplified by Frederick Douglass and his actions. Born as a slave on a plantation, Douglass experienced great mental distraught and consternation at the sight of his master beating and mistreating his family and other African-American slaves around him. Later, Douglass realizes that black men are not inherently inferior to whites but are forced to believe so because of their ignorance and subjugation. Because of this epiphany, Douglass rebelled against his masters and escaped from slavery, running away to New York. With his newfound freedom, Douglass had multiples opportunities to pursue further education and acquire a well-established and paying job. Instead, Douglass became an abolitionist activist, pursuing a profession that paid less but allowed him to fulfill his desires of making his story and ideals known to the public.

As literature such as Invisible Man and historical figures such as Douglass illustrate, it is much more important for people to follow their desires and ambitions through their professions instead of money and affluence. The ideal that following one’s beliefs is more important than acquiring money does not have to only be applied to professions though. It can also be applied to all decisions and experiences in life. As Martin Luther King once stated, “Money and power may satisfy you for a moment but following your heart will fulfill you forever.”

This is a good essay! Not much major grammatical mistakes made and the content of the essay works effectively to support your stance on the question.

Your introduction is rather interesting - it goes the extra mile compared to most other introductions and utilizes a real world example to set your answer to the prompt. It was, admittedly, a little confusing as I assumed that you had skipped the introduction and had immediately started giving an example. As an introduction is best left straight to the point, I would recommend that you cut to the important details about Gandhi (e.g. simply having ‘Although a well-established lawyer with an education from Britain and experience in South Africa, Gandhi was only able to find satisfaction by fighting for his country’s independence and by aiding those who were less fortunate than himself’ will suffice for his relevance to the question). I would also recommend that you mention the title of the work of literature and the name of the historical figure that you will be using in your Introduction.

The content of your first example suits the nature of the question, although you may wish to emphasize the fact that the narrator is well-paid - the only two clear indicators are ‘well-paid speaker’ and ‘well-paying job’. Perhaps add one more sentence detailing how the narrator was able to buy new clothes, or pay back Mary. A major grammatical mistake in the fifth sentence - you use ‘it’s’ when it should be ‘its’. Make sure you don’t make the same mistake, because the markers pay particular attention to these kinds of errors! Other than these, nice range of vocabulary, and tying the content to the question raised by the essay.

I have almost nothing bad to say about your second example. Once again, it is very relevant to the issue that you are addressing and bolsters your stance effectively.The only thing I can say is to watch your tense in the fourth sentence - the paragraph is written in the simple past tense (e.g. Douglass experiencED), but you then use ‘Douglass realizeS’. Not a major error, but it’s something to take note of.

Unfortunately, your conclusion is a bit weak compared to the strengths of your examples. The first and last sentence are fine, and should definitely not be changed as they strongly reiterate your belief. However, though the question deals with ‘work’, you attempt to widen the scope of your argument by saying that it can apply to situations outside of ‘professions’. There’s nothing strictly wrong with this, but take special care to ensure that you explain IN DETAIL how your belief can extend to other parts of life outside of ‘professions’, and how ‘work’, ‘fulfilling’, and ‘pays well’ are different in these cases. For instance, when you decide to help a friend with his homework instead of going for that Bruce Springsteen concert, what exactly ‘pays well’ in this scenario? You probably won’t receive extra money from your friend. As you can see, widening the scope of your argument takes a great deal of effort, almost to the point that it won’t fit in a conclusion. Unless you’re sure you can give a convincing conclusion, it would be best to stick with the main idea of the question.

10/12. A great essay that could move up one or two scores if you gave a bit more elaboration in your first example, cut the occasional grammar mistakes, and tidied up your introduction and conclusion a bit.

Ok, Thank you for your advice!

Where’s your intro? Are you going right into your first example?

“rather than what achieves him money.”
Not grammatically correct – you don’t achieve money, and you certainly don’t achieve someone money.

“This notion has also been exemplified by historical figures and American literature.”
Now this sounds like an introduction? Introductions are supposed to be broad, not examples unto themselves.

“One compelling illustration”
I’d use another word here. Split up by the commas as it is, the sentence sounds like you’re talking about a literal illustration.

“by the novel, Invisible Man, by Ralph Ellison”
Proper nouns don’t need the commas.

“Seeking to promote egalitarian ideals where he lives, Harlem, New York, the narrator decides to join an organization called the “Brotherhood” as a well-paid speaker.”
Not grammatically correct – things get wonky when you use commas where something like em dashes or parentheses should be. Besides that, you don’t really need “where he lives.” “Seeking to promote egalitarian ideals in Harlem, New York…”

“to further it’s duplicitous schemes”
As GeckoMoria noted, *its.

“The protagonist follows what he felt would bring him satisfaction”
You switched tenses… *feels will

“and his actions.”
This is vague and doesn’t add a whole lot to the sentence.

“Douglass experienced great mental distraught and consternation”
“Distraught” is not a noun. The noun form is “distress.” And “consternation” is a weaker feeling than I think you want here… Was he really just dismayed or generally annoyed by the beatings? Because that’s what consternation means.

“Douglass rebelled against his masters”
As already said, tense switch.

“Douglass had multiples opportunities”
*multiple

“pursuing a profession that paid less”
Is activism really a profession? Can you BE a professional activist?

“it is much more important for people to follow their desires and ambitions through their professions instead of money and affluence.”
Confusing syntax; could be interpreted any number of ways. What I think you’re trying to say is that they should follow their dreams, not money. But you could also say that this means they should do it through professions, not affluence. Or that it should be people who are doing this, not money and affluence.

“Money and power may satisfy you for a moment but following your heart will fulfill you forever.”
Just Googled this and could not find it anywhere.

Thanks! As I stated earlier, that is a made up quote :stuck_out_tongue: