Chance me?

I have a 28 raw act, 1250 sat, 3.32 unweighted gpa and 3.5 weighted. 3 year baseball letterman, 4 year tennis letterman, NHS 4 years. From Arkansas.

Schools I am applying to: Drexel University, Temple University, Depaul Universtiy, Duquesne University, Pitt, LMU, LoyolaNO, USC (reach), NYU (reach)

agree w/ your assessment that NYU and USC are reaches.
The rest should be strong possibles with maybe Pitt a borderline reach.
as an aside, your ACT of 28 looks stronger than your 1250 SAT.
assume you have considered finances for these - many of them are $$$.

^