<p>If you really don't like reading/analyzing stuff, Chicago is probably a bad fit. But a huge number of people don't really have an experience with tackling texts in a rigorous way before college, so it's also probably pretty difficult to know how you'll like courses in the humanities until you've done it.</p>
<p>On the other hand, people very sure of what they want (i.e. not dead set on a professional track) is a very UChicago thing, I think.</p>
<p>The other four reasons you have listed are pretty decent ones. (Again, if you really do hate humanities, then Chicago is probably not the best). Chicago is definitely a good general foundation for just about anything you could ever want to do from being the General Manager of a baseball team to a doctor to a university professor to a public policy maker to an economist to, with training afterwards, an engineer (I think the world would be a better place if engineers when to the University of Chicago first -- then again I think the world would be a better place if most people went to UChicago before getting trained in a narrow field). The exposure to a variety of disciplines and the rigorous environment get you conditioned to think about things more thoroughly than the typical person. I also think attending college in a place that is different from your home is a good idea. College is a unique opportunity to live in a place with no commitment to stay there past a certain, relatively short, timeframe.</p>
<p>This is coming from someone who applied at the very last minute mostly because the application was more interesting than others, after another EA application didn't work out, and who decided to attend, honestly, because it was the best school I got into that wasn't in a fairly small town, and I had a distant relative who went to Chicago and loved it. I'm pretty serious at academics, but I hate math (I haven't touched it since first year). </p>
<p>Again, from reading internet discussion board posts, it's hard to tell if you are a poor fit, or just really self-aware (i.e. most people, despite their professed interest in everything, when it comes down to it, are probably not going to actually take courses in a wide variety of subject areas). Some people really are into everything; however, many they respect a variety disciplines but have a few that they would rather spend their time with because specific aspects of other disciplines don't appeal to them. </p>
<p>I would say that if you could visit and sit in on a Humanities or Social Science core class, that would be a really good idea. If you really hate what goes on in there, then you probably would be pretty unhappy at Chicago. If you find yourself interested, then Chicago is probably fine for you.</p>
<p>Another consideration is how directly you want your college experience to relate to life afterwards. (i.e. do you want it to be specific content prep for grad school or more general practice at thinking rigorously and analytically) If you want pre-professional/pre-career training, Chicago is the wrong place. If you want skills that will help you be really effective in many different professions/disciplines, then Chicago may be the right place.</p>