CMU in Qatar or UWM, Please help me!

Hey guys.

I am an international student. I got accepted to both Carnegie Mellon University in Qatar, Doha Education City, and University of Wisconsin-Madison. I major in Computer Science. Now I have a difficult choice. Can anyone helps me?

One upperclassman in CMUQ told me that, though the CS in CMUQ may be not as good as that in Pittsburgh campus, the CS in CMUQ is still quite strong. The officials declare that the professor are from main campus, or trained in there. And I will receive the same degree and diploma in CMUQ as on the main campus. However, the upperclassman told me that through the teaching quality is fine, there are few directions of CS for you to choose because the limited number of professors. He has to contact with the professor in main campus through Skype and other internet methods to finish his undergraduate research. I think this may cause great difficulty for students to continue their studies. And I think CMUQ may not offer some upper courses for junior and senior.

Besides, I am worried about the employment of graduates. I know CMU maintains a great reputation in job market, especially its CS. But when you graduate from CMUQ, you may have less opportunities to attend the career fair in main campus, in the United State. And companies may not consider a student from CMUQ. And I will not gain OPT, which allows me to find a job in USA in 12 months. Is there anyone knows any information about this issue?

If CMUQ could not offer the courses I want to learn, I may consider to go to main campus through internal transfer or other universities in the Unites States. The FAQ on the official website says that transfering to main campus is quite difficult. but it doesn’t mention how difficult it is or any statistic. And that is what I am worrying about. Is it just a day dream?

My parents hope me to choose UWM. Of course the CS department in UWM is fairly good too, but CMU have a better reputation and education. Besides, CMUQ has a much higher teacher-to-student ratio. I think this may cause a great difference in education quality between CMUQ and UWM.

But in UWM, I don’t need to worry about transferring to other colleges. I may have a more stable college career. In CMUQ, there is always something uncertain, the information on Internet is too limited. That is what I thought and what my mum said.

I don’t want to work in Qatar after graduation. My original destination is America, not Qatar (Yes, the totally different culture is also a great problem to me). Now I cannot decide which one to go. Is there anyone studies in CMUQ or knows any information?

Guys, I need your help! Please HELP me! Thanks!

I’d go with UWM.

Any reason, please? @DarkEclipse

Comparing to UWM or CMU main campus, CMUQ just doesn’t stand up. Plus, CMUQ is very young, and hasn’t exactly developed academically yet, so again, education quality at UWM is superior. Diversity-wise, I can’t say. Plus, it’s getting harder for internationals to obtain long term work visas, so I think UWM would make that transition easier, but then again, studying in the US does not guarantee work in the US. And what do you mean a higher teacher-to-student ratio? How big is the difference?
CMU main campus may have a better reputation, but CMUQ does not.
That being said, CMUQ is a good school, but UWM is better.

@DarkEclipse Well, Thanks for your advices.

CMUQ have mush less students in its CS department (about 100-120), with 10 CS professor. This means that professor can pay more attention to every student. I think this may affect the teaching quality.

So CMUQ has a 12:1 as opposed to UWM’s 17:1. Not that much of a difference, so I still vote for UW-Madison.

Bump

What are your goals? Where can you work? Keep in mind that it will be tough for an International undergraduate to get a work visa in the US. No chance from CMUQ (your odds of transferring in to CMU CS from CMUQ round to zero).

If you’re aiming for a PhD program in the US, yes, Wisconsin would be more impersonal but would offer more research areas and classes.