Current Students - Why do you like/dislike McGill?

<p>I’m currently in science, but plan to do a ‘liberal’ major so I can have 2 arts minors- McGill is flexible in this sense.</p>

<p>Some Pros:</p>

<p>Your degree will be worth something, more than any other Canadian school
It’s an accepting environment
Montreal is a wonderful city
Relatively affordable</p>

<p>Some Cons:
The workload is a *****. You can get stuck with t.a.'s that don’t give marks above 60% if their life depended on it
Canadian school with the highest proportion of snotty kids
Only Canadian school where it’s easy to feel average/below average
First and Second year classes are LARGE</p>

<p>Don’t be surprised if your high school marks drop by 20 percent or more</p>

<p>Hello everyone…</p>

<p>I’m an international from Bahrain, who just got accepted to McGill Engineering (mechanical) a few days back. Well none of the above posts really mentioned a word about McGill’s engineering - but I do believe that it’s as challenging as the other departments, obviously. And that’s what I love - challenges. Alright, that’s besides the point. So could anyone here really give an honest account of what a McGill ENGINEERING experience may hold for someone who’s always loved learning, has a sound academic background (SAT Subjects- 2400, Reasoning-2270, and a 94% plus throughout school-years), loves to get engaged in hands-on learning and research, loves Nature and is really open-minded about relishing the diversity that McGill has to offer ? And how different would that be from Waterloo’s or Toronto’s for that matter?</p>

<p>Oh, and something more specific - Any ideas about when McGill starts sending out scholarship notifications ? … </p>

<p>And by the way, I’ve applied to the US Ivies as well (and i’ve received acceptances from Uni. of Southern California and U.Virginia too), but considering what a miserly bunch they are when it comes to providing financial assistance for foreign students, I’m really looking up to McGill to save the day (they do offer considerable aid). </p>

<p>Thanks !</p>

<p>mashallah u have OUTSTANDING grades…</p>

<p>mcgills engineering program is great as compared to their business or arts programs that most of the ppl here are applying to, but if u can afford it, Virginia Tech is much better as an engineering scholl as compared to mcgill, but mcgill is still pretty good. Colleges in the US are awfully expensive.</p>

<p>My overall experience at McGill was largely positive and I wouldn’t trade it.</p>

<p>I enjoyed the academic rigor of my classes, though I did bemoan the lack of/ disorganization of resources (lab/classroom space; research/funding opportunities) and the ensuing competition for them (but hey, that’s life!). A major improvement from my time is the streamlining of the internship application and funding process for students in the Faculty of Arts. The Faculty of Science, has also gotten their act together in helping students obtain research positions; the CAPS website has some good research postings. CAPS was particularly ineffectual during my time.</p>

<p>It’s a very good thing that the administration is investing in infrastructure whether it be sprucing up existing buildings or constructing new ones, the downtown campus felt a bit snug at times!</p>

<p>Academic advising, given the size of the university, is shabby. Heaven forbid you are in a bind and need immediate assistance from an adviser. The experience of meeting with an adviser is comparable to accessing Canadian health care: very long wait times with often no result. Unfortunately, I don’t think , academic advising has improved all that much over the years.</p>

<p>While, the physical library holdings aren’t shabby, McGill’s access to online journals has always been impressive. It seems that they’ve gotten better with time as have the physical spaces in the libraries themselves. </p>

<p>Similarly, I have always been impressed by the other IT offerings: from the great wi-fi all over campus even back in the day (it may seem like a given, but wait till you visit some fancy private US universities which still have spotty/no wi-fi access in parts of their campus), to the online lecture recordings (at least in the Faculty of Science), and the ability to access email/Minerva/WebCT/print stuff in libraries using one username and password.</p>

<p>Another big plus: being smack in the middle of the downtown core of a vibrant, safe, walking friendly city like Montreal! Like they say in real estate: location, location, location! Living in a city like Montreal is a very educative and enhancing experience in itself.While I appreciated the city during my time, I now rue the fact that I didn’t explore it as much or take advantage of its Francophone sensibilities.</p>

<p>The drinking and the lack of hand holding (though it’s very unfortunate that many students end up free-falling through the cracks) didn’t perturb me. I expected both these traits of a large public university in a liberal city like Montreal. </p>

<p>One size doesn’t fit all, and that’s especially true of McGill. Prospective students should do their research very well before deciding to come here. You’re doing yourself a big disservice if you think you’ll be able to somehow parlay McGill’s stellar reputation into big life gains, without being affected by the somewhat gritty spirit of the university or the manner in which the university functions. </p>

<p>McGill is a prestigious university, without many of the warm, cuddly amenities that students expect of institutions of equivalent caliber.If you are able to adjust and do well at McGill your chances of succeeding in life are pretty good.</p>

<p>p.s. The international composition of the student body is great; I made friends from all the inhabitable continents and thus have places to crash when I visit these places now! However, there isn’t much interaction between the out-of-province and international kids who live on campus and the students from Quebec, who comprise the majority of the student population, who live off-campus. Similarly, the town-gown relations aren’t the best either.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>As a point of comparison, there is an entire thread on CC under New York University re: the availability of fake Id’s and how likely it is that you can get past the bouncers in NYC clubs. At McGill, you do not have to deal with that cr**.</p>

<p>@FVirile </p>

<p>Since u know a lot about Mcgill, what is the business program there like?
thanks</p>

<p>bump !</p>

<p>@sheheryar the bcom program is relatively easy compared engineering and sciences. It’s not the best commerce program in Canada but it does carry the mcgill name so thats an advantage of queens or uoft. all the grades are curved to 65%-75% though its usually around 70-75 which is a B. Fortunately due to the sheer number of dumb kids in the program is fairly easy to get an A. No disrespect just stating the facts. Anyways its not hard, the business program is more focused on management than anything else. thus the faculty of management. you’re not gonna be able to take many electives if you come in as a u1 so beware of that. otherwise it has a strong international management program and is pretty decent.</p>