I agree with lots of what’s been posted (with the caveat that my daughter has just started the process and has not gotten in yet). She has only had the goal of costume design since the beginning of junior year. Her school only really has drama as a couple of classes (she took the one tech class they have) and mostly as an EC–they do one play and one musical a year. She was a performer sophomore year and then has been working behind the scenes since junior year.
Her portfolio includes set design sketches and photos (both in the process of being built and finished) of the productions she has worked on as the student costume designer and scenic artist, but is mostly a lot of (non-theatre) studio art (drawing, watercolor, collage) she has done in her art classes. All of this is in a pretty large (20x30"?) multi-ring, zip portfolio with clear insert pages, because some of her pieces are big. It was fairly pricey ($70ish), but as an artist, I know she’ll need to have one eventually anyway. She likes cosplay, so brings along part of a costume that she made (and photos of her in it), as well as her art sketchbook.
Most of the schools we have been to for theatre school visit days have said that they are looking for enthusiasm and potential, not finished perfection. They definitely get that most kids don’t go to performing arts schools and have been very open to taking a look at her portfolio and giving advice. I will say that the interviewer she met with yesterday asked her to upload digital files of the physical work onto the school’s portal website when she got home, so that they would have all of it for reference when they eventually make a decision. So maybe not a bad idea to put stuff online as well.
Time management has definitely been challenging, especially because she is not particularly interested in the minutia of application details. Her school has juniors take a college counseling class spring quarter and then another fall quarter of senior year. In that junior class, they start brainstorming for essay topics and put in requests for their teacher recs so those can get done over the summer. Most of the kids have until mid-late October to get their essays really rounded out in the fall class, but because theatre majors have to go through the interview process and most of those can’t be scheduled until the Common App is in, we were shooting for the second week in September and she managed to get it actually ready to go only about 2 weeks late, around the end of the month. It was critical to have an early meeting with her college counselor, as she had no experience with her major, little with the BFA process, and no idea as to the quantity of applications and requirement for early appointment-making. The Common App for some schools requires more than one essay, so it’s really a good idea to get logged into that as soon as it opens for the fall. There is also a ton of generic info to get filled in on it, so get ahead of that and just have your kid spend some time on data entry. Whatever you can do to just get that stuff out of the way early is really time well spent. Putting together a resume of high school classes, honors, activities, etc over the summer really makes this part go much faster. I won’t lie–I did have to nag her a lot to get it done, and I did help her get the generic data all collected into one reference document. And I did the data entry for the parental info part of her Common App so that I didn’t have to just sit there and dictate everything to her. The rest of the app was all her responsibility.
It seems like a lot to get done early, but having all of this collected made it so much easier for my D to be able to work her fall play (which was in rehearsal all of October, right when we were aiming to get her Common App in). I took on the piece of the puzzle that involved setting up her interviews, since she was at school during almost all business hours and there were a lot of moving parts. I made a list of emails that she needed to send out to the admissions people for initial contact, and then any additional pure scheduling emails that needed to be sent were sent by me under my email address. Lots of the scheduling was done online. She is doing 4 interviews on campus (Fridays and Saturdays) and we’ll be going to Unifieds in NYC for 5 or 6. We picked NYC because it is over a weekend, versus Chicago Unifieds that are during the week. Fortunately, two of her on-campus ones were able to be scheduled on teacher workdays. The others will be excused absences in November and January because they are college-related. It is possible they will overlap with winter musical rehearsals, but she is just going to have to miss a couple days. Big picture is a bigger deal.
Sorry for the LONG response! I hope it is helpful. Just remember to get the info all pulled together and work on the essay over the summer. I think you could probably even set up an account on the Common App website under your own email just to take a look at what your kid’s prospective colleges are asking for in their essays this year and the generic data that s/he’ll need for the rest of it.