Hello, @costumetechmom! Welcome to this wild and wonderful process. What an interesting path your son has chosen. I absolutely agree with @supergirlsmom: the college admission process was twice as hard as for kids without interview/portfolio/auditions!
Of course your family will customize the process, but I see commonalities in all the design & tech people’s experiences. It’s true that the portfolio is, if not ALL-important, the MOST Important Thing, at least in costume design. But what that portfolio looks like? It looks like your son’s experiences distilled into whatever form best represents his work. There is no one recipe for the portfolio. Bringing a costume piece as the designers above is great (love the puppet). My daughter took a binder full of budgets, costume plots, and all kinds of pre-production stuff, and she received great feedback for that. She also included her set design work for a show her HS put on last fall. She had very little artwork to show that wasn’t design-related; others could have quite a bit. She included photos of some side projects she had done, however. Photos of her pieces in realized productions, alongside copies of research, sketches, and watercolors were very well-received. If you have access to photos of the clothing “in action,” rather than just on a mannequin, it shows really well. She mounted her pieces on thin black boards, 20"x30", I think (huge). They were about $3 apiece, but they will last for years and they look really great! I think they will keep their looks much longer than foam core, and I really wanted them to last for this very long portfolio review season. We got them at an art supply shop.
We visited Rutgers, BU, and Emerson junior year, Penn State over the summer, Montclair St. fall senior year, and VCU when she went for a portfolio review. We also visited U of MD, as we are in MD. They have a gorgeous theatre and a BFA for acting, but only an MFA in design. The BA in Theatre seems solid, but undergrads rarely get any design work, they told us, so she did not apply. UM Baltimore County (UMBC), by contrast has a BA in Design and Technical Theatre and it looks like an excellent program. If she hadn’t been set on a BFA, it would have been high up on the list.
We intended to visit more schools, but time seems to fly senior year, plus of course they are IN THEATRE, so that is the number one priority in everyone’s lives every second! In hindsight, probably would have visited a few more junior year or seen if any schools had open houses in summer. Generally, I had been trying to avoid visiting in summer, since that student vibe is toned down so much, but when we went to Penn State, we had a quite nice visit. A lot of theatre faculty were present and we still got a nice sense of the campus and the town.
My D started with about 13 programs on her big list. She was almost entirely East Coast focused, and she displayed an admirable consciousness of our relatively shallow pockets. Both my husband and I followed our own liberal arts passions and have a great quality of life but not an enormous income. We do have college savings for the kids, and we told her she could certainly apply to CMU, or NYU, or BU, but she needed to understand going in that she’d be to a degree dependent on their generosity. Last summer she narrowed down her list, striking off CMU, sight unseen, and both BU and Emerson. I asked why. Well, one feature of BU really stuck out (to all of us): the students seemed great. But at one point, they were telling us very enthusiastically how their professors are often away working and they communicate every few days via Skype, and how cool that is. Fantastic! How much money are we paying for this privilege?? She said she wanted to be in a program where she’s going forward. She has been in a great theatre program during HS and has learned a tremendous amount from her theatre teacher. But as far as actual costume design—and sewing—she’s taught herself quite a bit. In college, for her core courses, she wants professors who are there, on campus, to TEACH HER THINGS! Not every second, but she would not think it was cool to skype for a whole semester. Having heard about supergirl’s experience, I’m just as glad it dropped off the list. As for Emerson, everyone was very nice. We were there with probably 50 other kids, almost all actors and stage managers. The tour was extremely student led, and with such a large group and such a spread out campus, I think maybe it just seemed a little casual and unfocused. She just didn’t fall in love with it.
Rutgers she loved right off. I think the idea of a traditional campus appealed to her, once she saw it. Here are your performance and design spaces, here’s an actual dorm, here’s a dining hall, here’s the movie theatre, here is your bike rack, this is College. I think for her, it’s appealing to say: this is a neatly defined space that will be your laboratory and academy for the next four years. Montclair, VCU, Penn State all looked like that. She clicked with the faculty at all four of those schools, too. As a parent, I would have been thrilled to send her to learn from any of those teachers, too. They all seemed beloved by their students (at U of MD, too) and went out of their way to speak to the parents. This is something I never would have expected, but I have to admit I enjoyed! Purchase we never got to, DePaul we never got to.
I agree with the need for fit. Academic, financial, geographical, and I guess I would say philosophical fit. I felt as if each of the schools she applied to had a strong culture of career preparation. She did not want to be in NY, but she definitely realized along the way that she wanted to be near a strong theatre city. That being said, UNCSA is far, far from NY, and its design and tech graduates are in great demand. It’s all about fit!
So my best advice is nothing new: Show ‘em everything you’ve got. Do as much reading and research about schools as you can. Plan your senior year travel to Unifieds or wherever so you can pack in additional fact-finding. Oh, one another helpful thing: my D qualified for Nationals at her state International Thespian Society festival. She raised the money to go to Nebraska last year and was adjudicated by college professors and/or working professionals. Between that experience and the state festival, she had a great idea of what portfolio reviews would be like. It was a GREAT experience. Also—apply to YoungArts or similar competitions. My daughter received a merit award, which brought no cash, but was a wonderful thing to put on a college application AND makes use of the same material you’re using for your portfolio anyway.
Not sure how coherent this sounds, but hope it helps! Best of luck to your S and you, and I’m sure I’ll be chiming in again!