Delayed Acceptance to Harvard, should I take it?

<p>Hi, I got accepted yesterday to harvard and for a minute I was euphoric but then I realized it was for the class of 2017. Is it worth it to wait one year for Harvard?</p>

<p>This wouldn't be a hard choice, but I've already committed to MIT. I definitely want to major in science (probably biology) but I also want to take a lot of humanities classes. I'm really interested in Biology, CS, and political science. Oh, and I'm also aware of cross registration.</p>

<p>Durring the gap year I could maybe work on the Obama campaign, travel or do an internship.</p>

<p>Is it worth it to wait?</p>

<p>Are you a little bit burned out on school?</p>

<p>I like the idea of a gap year, personally, and it sounds like a good year to take one, if you want to work on a campaign. Kids who take a gap year, with a reason, tend to do very well when they get back to school.</p>

<p>But, MIT is a whole other kind of school, imho, and if you want MIT, you should go with that.</p>

<p>JMO</p>

<p>Gap years are great!!! Well that is if you do something good with it. :slight_smile: Wait why were you accepted to the class of 2017 and not 2016? Or did you choose to delay?</p>

<p>Friends of mine have a son that got Z-listed. He was a legacy and Z-listers are often legacies.</p>

<p>Quite a few of his mother’s Harvard friends tried to convince him that a gap year would be awesome and that Harvard was worth waiting for, but he was just mentally ready to move ahead with college and didn’t want to wait.</p>

<p>I’d do the gap year.</p>

<p>The son of some good friends was similarly Z-listed two years ago. He had to decide in a few days whether to cobble together a gap-year plan in a hurry, or go to Columbia as he’d been planning.</p>

<p>I told him that I thought taking the gap year and going to Harvard was better than going straight to Columbia only if he could do something he really wanted to do, or something he couldn’t do during or after college, with that year. Otherwise, it was kind of losing a year in order to exchange the life-changing educational experience he’d have at Columbia for the life-changing educational experience he’d have at Harvard.</p>

<p>In your case, because MIT is so different from Harvard, maybe the bar is a little lower. But the general principle still applies. Probably only you can judge whether gap year plus Harvard is better for you than MIT now. But I think that in order for it to be better, you’ve got to have a clear plan for what you’ll do with that year. And if it’s a close call, I think you should go to MIT as you originally planned.</p>

<p>I don’t mean to gainsay what poetgrl said about gap years. I think they’re a great idea; I think they do a lot of undergraduates a lot of good. And I really hope I’m right, because my oldest is just finishing up a gap year before college right now! But a gap year is a serious thing to undertake, and I would hesitate about just slapping one together because you suddenly got a phone call from somebody with an office on Brattle Street. Because, realistically, this isn’t your only chance to take one. If you go to MIT, you can still take a leave of absence, and take some kind of gap year during your time there.</p>

<p>Honestly, it is a very hard decision. Happily, there’s no really bad choice here. You have two terrific offers in hand. Congratulations on that.</p>

<p>If it matters at all, it’s quite common to meet people who’ve taken a year or two off, for a variety of reasons. Whether you think the year off would be beneficial is up to you, but don’t decide against it because you think it would be weird or keep you from fitting in - it wouldn’t.
Good luck!</p>

<p>sikorsky, we are in complete agreement, actually.</p>

<p>If financial resources are not an issue, there are many worthwhile things you can do in the coming year and it isn’t too late to look into them.</p>

<p>Working for the campaign will only last through November, so you’ll want to look into something else for after that. Volunteer on a kibbutz or an organic farm, do a language immersion program, etc.</p>

<p>Does the Z-list prohibit you from enrolling for credit in another university for a semester as a guest student? Some foreign universities offer this as an option and that would be a fun way to combine an international travel experience with a college experience.</p>

<p>If your finances are limited, then your options are more limited and it might be harder to find something to do that would be as enriching as a freshman year at MIT.</p>

<p>As a biology major are you interested in pre-med. If so, I would definitely take the gap year and go to Harvard, which probably has one of the two or three best biology and pre-med programs in the country. MIT grades are lower, which hurts for med school, where GPAs rule. Also, if you check out the schools sending lots of people to med school (go to AAMC web site for this), MIT is not in the Top 50. This gives you a rough idea how much resources a school devotes to pre-med activities. At MIT it is not a big priority. </p>

<p>If you are not interested in medicine though, I would stick with MIT unless you really can think of something good to do in the gap year.</p>

<p>@blinelight,
If you are pre-med, this article might interest you about MIT:
[MIT</a> ? the premed?s choice? - The Tech](<a href=“http://tech.mit.edu/V131/N18/bandler.html]MIT”>http://tech.mit.edu/V131/N18/bandler.html)</p>

<p>Just because a school does not send a lot of students at med schol does not mean that the program itself is not top quality but that there are not that many students as in other schools interested in medicine. MIT also has a solid political science dept and humanities, which is something that people underestimate. You can easily attend MIT and then do research during the year or summer in any of the hospitals or the biomedical companies and research institutions that surround MIT like Broad, etc.</p>

<p>This is from MIT admissions that stresses that the MIT has an advantage for those interested in academic medicine (research and Md-PhD are treasured in all the HMS-affiliated hospitals)
[So</a> You Wanna Be a Doctor? | MIT Admissions](<a href=“http://mitadmissions.org/blogs/entry/premed]So”>So You Wanna Be a Doctor? | MIT Admissions)</p>

<p>If it was a different school I would say go for the gap year, but for any HYPS/MIT, I do not think it is worth it to waste a year.</p>

<p>I would simply go to MIT.</p>

<p>A student can attend any college, major in any subject, and eventually matriculate at a top-tier med school. A high school student really shouldn’t be worried about getting into med school when selecting a college. College is the time to get a broad-based liberal arts education, learn how to learn, make lots of friends, and stack up life experiences so that one can make an informed decision about a future career.</p>

<p>Although both schools are located just a mile or two down Mass. Ave. from one another, each school has a very different feel. When I applied to college (way back when), I was fortunate enough to receive acceptances from both Harvard and MIT, among other schools. After visiting the campuses and staying a weekend with host students, the choice was clear for me…Harvard. The Harvard Pre-Frosh weekend, renamed “Visitas” recently, is a lot of fun. You should check it out if you get the chance.</p>

<p>If you have a good plan for the gap year, I would encourage you to consider matriculating at Harvard in the Fall of 2013. When I was a Harvard Prefect (sort of like a Big Brother/Sister program for frosh), I had a couple of first-year students who had opted for the delayed-acceptance/gap-year package. Both ended up traveling, working, and doing community service for the gap year. On the whole, I would characterize them as more mature than the other first-year Harvard students – more serious about their studies, more organized, better attitude about life, etc. They didn’t struggle at all with the transition to college life.</p>

<p>If you’re itching to start college in the Fall 2012, then enroll at MIT or another school at which you were accepted. MIT has a lot going for it: strong science curricula, plentiful undergrad research opportunities, freshman year is pass/fail, etc.</p>

<p>I’m clearly biased, but I think you’ll have better access to excellent courses in bio, comp sci, and poli sci at Harvard.</p>

<p>On a side note, I cringe every time someone pronounces that his/her college major is/was “pre-med.” Major in a discipline that excites you, whatever it may be, and then take other courses to fulfill the med school prerequisites. If your interest happens to be dead foreign languages, then, by all means, major in Classics. If metabolic pathways float your boat, then major in Biochemistry. The only advantage of majoring in a science is that courses within one’s field of concentration might count as med school prerequisites. Humanities majors have to be a little more organized in terms of course-planning in order to fit in the necessary science courses, but it’s not a big deal either way. Alternatively, one could major in the humanities and take pre-med science courses after college graduation as extension courses or as part of a postbaccalaureate program. There’s no rush. In fact, med schools typically like more mature applicants who have some life experience after college. Those kinds of people often make the best physicians or physician-scientists. How do I know? I’m in an MD/PhD program right now. I have administered lots of student interviews for the med school, MD/PhD program, and grad program at my school. I have also served on the MD/PhD admissions committee as a student representative.</p>

<p>Choose the school that is the better match for you. MIT has some incredible project-based engineering courses. As you mentioned in your original post, Harvard students can cross-register at MIT for most courses. One of my roommates, who was concentrating in engineering, did just that. The only thing to watch out for is the increased travel time to/from class…and dealing with any discrepancies in the academic schedules. When I attended Harvard, we didn’t take our Fall semester finals until mid-to-late January (after winter break and a 2-week reading period starting Jan. 3/4). In recent years, the Harvard academic schedule has been revised to be aligned with those of other colleges.</p>

<p>Good luck with your decision.</p>

<p>As McGrath-Lewis and Fitzsimmons’ article that comes with the acceptance packet states, the data on those who have taken gap years is very strongly correlated with happiness and success in school. If you can wait-- even if you decide on MIT-- you will be better off.</p>

<p>My son (who is British educated where a very large percentage of his classmates take gap years) took a gap year-- he was “burnt out” and decided to student teach in the inner city before going to Harvard. He will tell you it was one of the best decisions he ever did–he was excited to start by time times September after gap year came. And if you are concerned that you will lose your academic chops-- he took Math 55 and didn’t think he missed a beat.</p>

<p>Some students and/or their parents can’t abide the idea of such an interruption – then don’t-- but I think that you will see that as is the case with top British students it will become very common–if not normative-- in top American universities in the years ahead.</p>

<p>Don’t have much to add to the many wise posts here. I’ll just say that I was never in a position that required me to take a gap year, but when I was a high school senior, the idea seemed outrageous and disadvantageous to me. Now that I’ve met boatloads of people at Harvard who took gap years, it doesn’t sound so crazy, and it might have been a good idea for me. You’re young and (I assume) you’re not racing death anytime soon. You can spare a year if it’s for something you really want.</p>

<p>Taking a gap wont makee you loose anything but one think in your mind that d u really want this gap? and go to Harvard or instead go to MIT this year itself… Both uni are excellent in there own way so what ever decision you take you wont be in the wrong path thats for sure… Wish you luck</p>

<p>If you are set on medical school and a female, don’t take gap year. Physician training is awfully long. If you have another gap year between college and medical school, you will have hard time to find time to have children. If you are male, the pressure is less. If you are not interested in medicine, there is no point to take gap year, because MIT is every bit as strong as Harvard in biology (half faculty members in MIT biology are NAS members if I tabulated correctly, plus 3 nobels, even Harvard biology does not reach this level of excellence).</p>

<p>Good point on the Female and male issue, although in this day and age more and more women are already delaying marriage and giving birth to kids later in life. Yet I believe that if the OP has already been accepted into Harvard for 2017, then he/she should just wait that extra year and be at one of the best Undergrad schools in the world. Besides, Harvard Undergrad students are the most represented at Harvard Medical School. If he likes he can do some soul searching in that Gap year and maybe even realize he likes another career path better. That would save him money and time.</p>

<p>Bad idea to take a gap year, considering one of the the possible things to do on your list :)</p>

<p>There really isn’t a point in a gap year, unless you’re dying to attend harvard. MIT is a great school so i’d say go with MIT, but if harvards really your dream…follow it.</p>

<p>Sent from my SPH-M930 using CC</p>

<p>I would choose MIT. Like riocarmenstar said, there’s no point in taking a gap year. I mean yeah you can join the Obama campaign and stuff like that, but it seems kind of like a waste of time. MIT is also an amazing school and if you’re interested in CS, it’s pretty much the best school there is for that type of science.
Plus, like you said, there is cross-registering, and I’m sure you can take some PoliSci classes at Harvard.
If you want to go into med, you’re already going to have to give up about 12 years to college/med school/etc, why prolong it?</p>