Early Decision is a BIG Decision.

Some kids don’t realize the weight of applying ED somewhere. I would know because I didn’t understand it until I did it (to Vanderbilt University in Nashville, TN). I didn’t think I stood a modicum of a chance of getting in with their 13% acceptance rate, but I really wanted to go for reasons related to my insecurities, and I got in. I’m here now because that’s how ED works; you’re BOUND to that school after you’re accepted and you graduate from high school. I wasn’t really ready to get in, honestly, and the school isn’t the greatest fit for me socially… and it hurt to realize that I wouldn’t be able to see what the other colleges I applied to would have said and offered me. There were lots of things I wish I had looked into before applying ED and getting accepted.

Just realize that ED is a HUGE decision. Don’t do it unless you are over 300% sure that the school you’re applying to is the school you want to go to for the next four years. You can always transfer, but you don’t want to have to do that. Just be careful and REALLY think about it. Good luck to all of you, and I wish you luck in the college application and admissions process!

And if you have any questions for me about my experience, or any advice I might have about college, applications, Vanderbilt, etc., go ahead – I’ll try to answer them! :slight_smile:

@Boulier Thank you for your post. D16 is not planning to apply to any schools ED because she is not sure about any of her colleges, but Vanderbilt is on the top of the list. If you don’t mind adding a little information about why Vanderbilt is not the greatest fit for you, I really appreciate it? We live in Colorado and I am worried that she wouldn’t like living in Tennessee.

Sure thing! For starters, I’m a racial minority (black) from Georgia, and while most of the students seem pretty accepting of different races, there are enough insensitive people or people who just have an issue with befriending or even respecting anyone of ANY racial minority. When people bring up broad issues they’re having here (like the head of my freshman dorm being called a racial slur by another student, as well as other things), the majority of students are apathetic. It’s disheartening.

On top of that, a point that will definitely be relevant for any student thinking of applying here – the party and Greek atmosphere here is huge. I’m not a partier, so I can tell you that if your child isn’t into partying or Greek life, it’s quite the challenge to find a friendly group. I luckily found one, but not everyone does. Those students usually end up transferring somewhere else. There’s a huge self-conscious pressure here to always look 100% (makeup, clothes, fashion in general), and I don’t feel like that’s a pressure that students at a Top 15 school should ever have to deal with, especially not at the levels that they do here. I guess that’s the quickest way to say that it’s not a great fit for me, and after being here for about six weeks, I’ve already considered transferring.

Now, let’s talk about positives! Vanderbilt is NOT a bad school. In fact, it is a FANTASTIC school in a lot of ways… just not the most wonderful fit for everyone. Tell your child to keep that in mind when selecting a college; acceptance rate and ranking aren’t everything. However, all of my professors are INCREDIBLE, inspiring, and brilliant. Even my TAs are wonderful. The coursework is pretty difficult, especially the science classes – chemistry being one of the toughest… fortunately, I’m NOT in that class :wink: Anyway, hard work is rewarded well.

One of the best things Vanderbilt does is something they don’t talk about a lot, called Vanderbilt Visions. We are assigned into small groups of about 16 other freshmen, an older student, and a staff member, so we can talk about issues on campus. It’s an awesome way to make friends with people you otherwise wouldn’t have interacted with, and it’s nice to have a place where everyone can be honest about being stressed and needing to vent. They also try really hard to make sure freshmen acclimate well; “orientation” lasts for about five days, including many scattered events throughout the first semester, and it really helps new students to get a feel for the campus and the atmosphere.

Not sure how much you are going to like Nashville’s climate, though. It’s strange, but I’m used to it because I’m from Atlanta (where the weather is just as strange). Very, very hot and humid in the summers and the fall (the high today was 86, and the humidity was around 70%)… I haven’t been here long enough to experience the rest of the seasons, but from what I’ve heard, things only really cool down after Thanksgiving. If you’re from Colorado, it’ll definitely be quite an adjustment. Nashville is a neat city, though; it’s growing rapidly, and there are a lot of things to do for students interested in exploring the city with their friends.

If you have anymore questions, I’d be glad to help! Hope this didn’t feel too much like rambling, but there’s a lot to say about the school, and I really hope this helps you and your child in your college decision(s). :slight_smile:

@Boulier Wow! An excellent post. THANK YOU!

First of all, I am so sad to read that you have encountered such a terrible racist behavior at Vanderbilt. Unfortunately, as you already aware, racists can be found anywhere in the country. D16 is half Middle Eastern, very liberal, and is not into partying or Greek life. She is not a typical girl, so she doesn’t care about makeup, clothing, or fashion, so fitting in might be a big problem for her.

Living in a state with 4 seasons (love the weather here), it would be a big problem for her to live in a very hot and humid environment. She picked Vanderbilt for their academic reputation and some recommendations from family members, so now I am bit concerned. However, I am glad to read about some of the great things you mentioned that they provide for freshmen on your post. I have heard freshmen year is usually very hard to adjust, so I wish you a lot of luck.

Thanks again. I will definitely show your post to D.

Don’t you get a two week window to opt out of Early Decision for financial reasons? I thought that was the case.

Yes, but the OP’s second thoughts weren’t due to insufficient FA.

But aren’t there EAs where it isn’t binding?

Yes, but every school does not have EA. Most have one or the other (ED or EA). I can only think of one school that has both (I think Dickinson has an ED and an EA round). ED is more common than EA. They want you to commit. Also, a few of the very top schools have restrictive EA plans (you can’t apply EA to some other colleges if you apply EA to them). But that is just a few schools.

@Boulier what would you say Vanderbilt’s overall “vibe” is? I’m having a really tough time deciding between it and Brown (I know they’re very different) and it would be super helpful to know what the general vibe is like - is it busy/quiet, high-pressure/chill, that kind of stuff.

@Boulier I applied ED to Vandy this year! I am Caribbean, and I am starting to become nervous as I read over all these threads involving racism with Vanderbilt. However, I’m legacy for tridelt so basically wherever I end up for school, I’ve been planning on rushing tridelt. Greek life was actually one of the reasons I was so drawn to Vanderbilt, but this whole issue with racism is a pretty big turn off! Hopefully if I am accepted next year, I can be one of the students who helps to address and correct this issue!

Just because you are a Greek legacy doesn’t mean you will get a bid. You will get more consideration but if the sister’s don’t think it’s a good fit it won’t happen. Go into rush with an open mind if you get into Vandy.

Hey, sorry it has taken me such a long time to respond here!

To answer collegebobollege – It’s a pretty quiet campus, and it’s usually not too busy, with a couple very isolated exceptions. Even on big game days, the campus is really quiet because most people head out to the games. One of the biggest days I can recall was when an SEC sports network came to the campus and “set up camp” in the freshman dorm area, but even then, things weren’t too hectic. If you’re not a partying student, then it’s especially quiet on Tuesdays, Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays (when the VAST MAJORITY of students are at a party or a bar somewhere). It’s rather high-pressure, though; students take their academics very seriously, and you’ll really see students buckling down during midterms and finals weeks. There isn’t much of a competitive vibe here, though; students are generally supportive of each other, and you rarely hear students express jealousy over someone getting a position or opportunity that they didn’t get. I definitely wouldn’t describe Vanderbilt’s atmosphere as “chill,” but that’s not necessarily a bad thing.