Extracurriculars in College Applications

I’m currently a sophomore in high school, so I still have a while before applying to colleges, but I’m quite concerned about what I have to share in terms of extracurriculars because it doesn’t really show who I am as a person. And on a side note, my academics are very well qualified, so there’s nothing to really worry about there.

I’ve had many extracurriculars growing up, including piano, drawing, martial arts, etc, however, my family situation has never been good, and has gotten worse and worse over the years and around 6th or 7th grade, I decided quit learning piano, drawing, and martial arts at the schools I learned them at so I could help out in the family by doing chores and whatnot when my parents were fighting (and to act as a pacifier), and I never reached any honorable level in either of my extracurriculars during the time I did them: I tested for piano every 4–5 levels out of the 10 levels there were in the program I learned from, and I ended up quitting piano 4 months before I tested for the last level, and the highest level I had tested for by then was only level 5, which is not very good or something that stands out; I was 2 belts away from black belt when I quit martial arts (red 1 and red black), but I was the best student in my class and I could beat all but 1 or 2 black belts during sparring, so it’s not like I didn’t qualify or anything, the program just required that I go through the belts one by one, which would’ve taken another year.

Even after I quit all those extracurriculars, I continued to practice them with passion at home, but since I’m not in any program and I have not competed in any tournaments or competitions, there’s absolutely no record of me practicing any of these extracurriculars (aside from me performing at my school’s talent show with piano every year). I’ve become very good at many of those extracurriculars that I’ve quit, and I’ve even taught some of my classmates and friends how to do some of them, such as guiding friends who also play the piano through their pieces and advising them on how to practice and manage the pieces that they’re learning.

My family situation has gotten even worse now, and my parents have decided to divorce after I go to college so they don’t affect me too much and so that I could focus more on high school and less on dealing with the loss of a family member or whatever the law is for a divorce. Because of this, I can’t just say my family situation is bad since there’s no evidence (there’s no divorce and no one really knows about it well aside from me talking about it).

If I don’t mention any of this, and tell colleges that I don’t have any extracurriculars (I have found a few, but they’re debatable between extracurricular and academic. If you’re what wondering what they are, they’re computer programming and math olympiad), I obviously wouldn’t be admitted into any of the better colleges. On the other hand, if I were to tell colleges that I quit my extracurriculars to help out my family, it would seem like an excuse for myself not to continue in any of those programs (possibly because I was terrible at it or forced to do it). On top of that, it won’t be easy talking about my family situation considering the complexity and risk in it. How should I go about telling colleges about this?

Time to think outside the box - the boxes you check on the app. You actually have better raw material to work with than the stereotypical student who has a polished app that lists awards and hours but no passion or exploration. AOs read thousands of apps from students who list many things but don’t say anything interesting or that reveals the inner self of the student.

You, on the other hand, are exploring and developing interests outside school. So what if you don’t have a “record” or “evidence” of your piano work, it’s not like you need to submit a punchcard from a time clock. You also don’t need to win awards to make the work meaningful. Is this work your sanctuary and something you continue to do on your own because it not only protects you from a family situation that you have no control over, but also feeds your soul? Not only that, but you share the love by tutoring others. That’s some powerful stuff! And could make for a very interesting story and essays. Maybe quitting formal lessons happened because your family could no longer afford it, but you continued to develop and grow on your own… that’s the sort of thing that colleges love!

Stop thinking about evidence, records and awards. Keep exploring those activities on your own and seeing how you can expand what you do and how involved you are. That’s enough; in fact, compared to a lot of the really boring lists of awards but no passion that many students present, your story and activities should actually work in your favor.

Good luck - keep it up.

Completely agree with advice above. ECs are really about passion. You have that. much better to take a deep dive than a surface level smattering of meaningless activities that everyone does.

It’s good to be thinking about your future but make sure you spend time in the present. High school is also a special time. Try to enjoy it (notwithstanding your personal situation). Don’t over think college at this point. Plenty of time for that.

I do not think you need to apologize for your extracurriculars or discuss your family situation in reference to them.

Write about what you do in a positive way:
Example: “Piano—practice 1 hour daily, help friends with their piano pieces, performed in school’s annual talent show (2016, 2017, 2018).”

If your family situation is mentioned at all, it should not be used by you as an excuse for inactivity… but rather be mentioned by your guidance counselor as a hardship you have faced but performed well in spite of, OR, if you can use it to show how you have grown/ assumed responsibility/ learned about yourself or others, then it might prompt an essay topic. But not as “woe is me”— that just looks bad. Decide when you are a senior.

You are a sophomore. You have plenty of time to get involved in one or more activities you truly enjoy. Either increase your involvement in piano and/or martial arts or join a school club. Do not worry about applications. You cannot know now what will be most significant to highlight, until you have lived it for a few years and are looking back on your high school years when you are ready to complete your application. Absolutely anything you do* can provide fodder for an interesting short blurb or essay. It’s all on how you talk about its significance to you. That is more important than having a long list of activities.

*That includes responsibilities you may have assumed for your family, like caring for a sibling or cooking dinners for your family or working a part-time job or whatever.

Personally, I think you have a compelling story; IMO quitting extracurriculars to help your family out, especially if you “continued to practice them with passion at home,” is great and definitely not just an excuse. Consider addressing this in your essay or Additional Info section. Best of luck!

I’m currently a sophomore in high school, so I still have a while before applying to colleges, but I’m quite concerned about what I have to share in terms of extracurriculars because it doesn’t really show who I am as a person. And on a side note, my academics are very well qualified, so there’s nothing to really worry about there.

I’ve had many extracurriculars growing up, including piano, drawing, martial arts, etc, however, my family situation has never been good, and has gotten worse and worse over the years and around 6th or 7th grade, I decided quit learning piano, drawing, and martial arts at the schools I learned them at so I could help out in the family by doing chores and whatnot when my parents were fighting (and to act as a pacifier), and I never reached any honorable level in either of my extracurriculars during the time I did them: I tested for piano every 4–5 levels out of the 10 levels there were in the program I learned from, and I ended up quitting piano 4 months before I tested for the last level, and the highest level I had tested for by then was only level 5, which is not very good or something that stands out; I was 2 belts away from black belt when I quit martial arts (red 1 and red black), but I was the best student in my class and I could beat all but 1 or 2 black belts during sparring, so it’s not like I didn’t qualify or anything, the program just required that I go through the belts one by one, which would’ve taken another year.

Even after I quit all those extracurriculars, I continued to practice them with passion at home, but since I’m not in any program and I have not competed in any tournaments or competitions, there’s absolutely no record of me practicing any of these extracurriculars (aside from me performing at my school’s talent show with piano every year). I’ve become very good at many of those extracurriculars that I’ve quit, and I’ve even taught some of my classmates and friends how to do some of them, such as guiding friends who also play the piano through their pieces and advising them on how to practice and manage the pieces that they’re learning.

My family situation has gotten even worse now, and my parents have decided to divorce after I go to college so they don’t affect me too much and so that I could focus more on high school and less on dealing with the loss of a family member or whatever the law is for a divorce. Because of this, I can’t just say my family situation is bad since there’s no evidence (there’s no divorce and no one really knows about it well aside from me talking about it).

If I don’t mention any of this, and tell colleges that I don’t have any extracurriculars (I have found a few, but they’re debatable between extracurricular and academic. If you’re what wondering what they are, they’re computer programming and math olympiad), I obviously wouldn’t be admitted into any of the better colleges. On the other hand, if I were to tell colleges that I quit my extracurriculars to help out my family, it would seem like an excuse for myself not to continue in any of those programs (possibly because I was terrible at it or forced to do it). On top of that, it won’t be easy talking about my family situation considering the complexity and risk in it. How should I go about telling colleges about this?

My younger son, a freshman, has a similar issue—his biggest time commitment outside of school, after a few sports certain times of the year, is playing music. He plays both drums and guitar, and has been trying to put and keep together a few amateur “garage” bands in addition to solo practice time. If he were in the School of Rock music program, he could just list that, but when a kid plays on their own it is a little harder to characterize. I agree with above poster—list it in essentially how it is but definitely list it.

I do alumni interviewers and I had a student who didn’t have many formal ECs because his parents were divorced and he watched his little brother after school. But in talking to him, I found that he showed much leadership doing this: He make sure his brother did his homework, asked his parents to sign brother up for base ball and then took him to practice, made him food, etc.