I can’t speak to the relative strength of each school’s economics department, but there isn’t much question in my mind that F&M is stronger in math. Dickinson’s advanced course offerings are quite limited (two classes per semester on average) and virtually no Dickinson alums go on to graduate school in mathematics and statistics (only two PhD completions in the last 20 years). F&M’s advanced offerings are somewhat limited as well (three or four classes per semester), but are at least sufficient to provide some student choice. There is some recent history of PhD completions, as well (two in 2012 alone and eight in the last decade).