<p>"until... i heard john williams playing hedwig's theme (from harry potter) on the radio. i immediately blurted out "HEY, THAT'S HARRY POTTER MUSIC!</p>
<p>a short awkward silence ensued and then she asked if i liked harry potter. and even here, i could have fixed it... but instead, i go "i love harry potter - its my favorite book series!"
having realized what i've just admitted to, i tried to humorously add "i know i'm not supposed to admit that to my dartmouth interview but you've caught me. i've been hiding it from all my interviewers."</p>
<p>she laughed and then went, "yeah, my niece and nephew love those books"
i ask about them and discover they are 4 and 5 years old. great so now my interviewer thinks of my like her 4 year old niece.</p>
<p>she did not leave the subject and asked why i like harry potter. seeing this as a place to try to salvage the remaining bits of my normal student reputation, i said "well.... i've learned a lot from it" and went on to talk about how it inspired me to write and such. and then, i slipped again "...and it's because of harry potter that i taught myself to knit. i've knitted two harry potter scarves... one ravenclaw and one slytherin</p>
<p>Nothing was bad about what you said. You sounded natural and funny.</p>
<p>The answer that you gave wouldn't keep you from a place like an Ivy. </p>
<p>Saying this as a Harvard alum interviewer.</p>
<p>The worst replies in Harvard interviews that I have conducted were from students who obviously were telling me what they thought I wanted to hear, not what really was their truth. One was from a guy who told me that his favorite book was "Oedipus Rex". When I asked "why", all he could do was summarize the story. As a result, it was obvious to me that he was lying about his favorite book -- just selected one that he thought would impress me.</p>
<p>I'm a rare person who finds the Harry Potter series boring. However, I know lots of smart people -- including adults and college students -- who include the series among their favorite books. I would find it interesting in a good way if a Harvard applicant did that, and I would be interested, too, in what the student found compelling about the series.</p>