<p>I'm a Yale freshman, and I finally created an account to answer this question. I had many reservations about going to Yale over other schools (I had many attractive options, somehow, luckily, or not so luckily in the end), but since I arrived in New Haven this summer, I have been absolutely certain that I made the right choice. This school is amazing. It will blow your mind every day how happy you are, how impressive your classmates are and how true the friendships you make will be. The one thing that I can say about Yale is that every Yalie absolutely wants to convince a prospective applicant that this is the place to go. Sometimes we get derided for "bashing" other colleges (which, of course, is not always good), but I think the underlying motive is that we GENUINELY, ABSOLUTELY believe that our school is the best (obviously this is subjective), better than any other school, and we can't see how anyone else could disagree.
I know a few other schools (all good, all in the same tier), in which apathy is seen as cool. School spirit is considered to be embarassing and for desperate people. If this is how you think, then don't come to Yale. We ooze school spirit. Yeah, we love this school.
Now, to answer your question...
1. My freshman seminar professor was amazing. He spends half the year off campus going to international conferences and collecting material/information for whatever latest book he's working on. Needless to say, he is an absolute authority on the subject. My current seminar prof is similarly impressive; we read texts that quote my professor's work. It may be impressive to read a book written by your professor, it's even more impressive to read a book in which the author reads your professor. :)
2. This year I've been in six courses that have less than 25 people. The other three all had discussion sections and probably hovered around 75-125 people.
3. This should be obvious. Yale is gorgeous, there are gyms in every college plus Payne Whitney, 12+ libraries, and tons and tons of money to update everything. Facilities should be the least of your worries.
4. Ah, dorms. Before I got to Yale I would pray not to live in Ldub or Morse/Stiles. Actually though, every dorm has its ups and downs. I'm lucky enough to live in a dorm without any drawbacks, but my friends in Ldub love it. It's a lot more socially cohesive than other dorms and there's always something going on. Plus, chances are if you come to Yale, you'll live in a castle.
5. There is a lot of statistical diversity at Yale, but more interesting than that is the diversity of interests. Truly, Yale can be whatever you want it to be. There are people who live down the entryway from me who live completely different lives; there are jocks, drama kids, acappella kids, artists, comedians, everyone.
6. EAT. There are amaaaaazing restaurants here. Cafe Adullis, Miso, Roomba, Pacifico, Barcelona, Thai Taste, Bulldog Burrito... the list goes on. There's also a movie theater, clothing stores, hair salons, pretty much anything a college kid would desire.
7. Yale is safe if you're careful. I'm accustomed to urban areas so I know how to behave in a city, but really if you're out off campus late at night, don't walk alone. Problem solved. You won't feel unsafe here -- that's probably the source of a lot of the incidents.
8. As you can probably tell, my experience has been unparalleled. This is THE school. That was the only way I could describe it to my mother. Yale is the ultimate school, and I love it. I hope you love it too.</p>