<p>I don’t know what precisely you said to the adrep, but based on what you’ve said here, it seems that the issue isn’t whether or not your D has met the requirements for Rice - clearly, she has - but whether or not she has enough of a math background to be a credible STEM applicant. I suspect that’s the spirit in which the adrep answered you.</p>
<p>There are two kinds of primarily academic admits to top schools: specialists - in other words, kids with a defined aptitude and passion for a particular subject - and what I’ve seen people here refer to as the BWRK, the Bright, Well-Rounded Kid. Colleges rely on BWRKs to raise their academic profile, so they’re going to have to have scores and grades at the high end of the school’s range - probably above the 75th percentile. The specialist can have somewhat lower (although still excellent) test scores and class rank. The catch is, in order to be credible as a specialist, he’s going to have to be really, really good - the kind of kid about whom teachers will say “among the best of my career.” And certainly, he should have taken advantage of whatever opportunities in that subject were available to him.</p>
<p>If your daughter wants to frame an application around an intended math/science major and has only very recently decided she wants to do math, no matter how good she is (unless she’s got some competitions or other evidence to back up her seriousness), she’s not going to be able to compete with people who have been doing four years of math olympiads and taking the hardest courses available (of course, if these opportunities haven’t been available at all, that’s another story). </p>
<p>Now, she can still apply to Rice as a BWRK with a possible interest in math among other things, and if she’s got scores within their range, she should, but just playing the odds, it becomes less likely than someone whose got a real hook, academic or otherwise. Getting into a top school as a BWRK is hard: there are a lot of them and, because they don’t fill any particular niche, they’re all competing against each other for the same spots. </p>
<p>None of this is intended to discourage you, but to emphasize the importance of applying widely - and to explain why your daughter’s record, while not a problem in itself, might be problematic if you’re applying as a certain type of student. Fortunately, you still have plenty of time to consider how best to package the application. Good luck!</p>