<p>There are very few schools where "everything" (meaning 100%) rides on the audition. Perhaps it may be so at a stand alone conservatory but it is not true anywhere else. Of course the audition is important. If they don't want you from the audition, it doesn't matter how great the rest of the package is. So, one must be chosen from the auditionees. However, there are usually more who meet the artistic standards they are looking for than slots available. Other factors enter into it for that reason itself. That is not the only reason, however. </p>
<p>A student must be qualifed to be accepted to the college or university itself in which the BFA program exists. Some BFA programs exist at schools that are not that academically selective and thus if you are often over a certain "bar", it likely is not an issue. But many of the BFA programs are in schools that do want the candidate to be admissable like any other college applicant, and they are selective and do not take all who apply. That decision whether to admit to the college is not just about GPA, rigor of courseload, rank, and SAT/ACT scores, though all of those things are important factors in admissions. Essays and recommendations, activity resumes, short answer questions, etc. all contribute in demonstrating who the student is. Many schools examine the application holitiscally. If they didn't care about essays and recs, they would not ask for them. Indeed, many BFA programs have additional essays beyond those that are required for regular applicants to the same college. Admission officers have said that they do read the essays and consider all these factors. I have heard this from adcoms from many BFA programs. Some BFA programs are in schools that are selective. NYU, for example, as a university, has a 28% admit rate. The application has one long essay and four short essays. Academics/application review is 50% of the admissions decision to Tisch. I believe the essays are very important. In fact, when my own kid was selected to be one of 15 Tisch Scholars (all of Tisch, not just Drama), and I learned the selection criteria after the fact in April (had had no idea such a program even existed until she was selected), I can see how things that she wrote about in the essays demonstrated some things they apparently were looking for, though we didn't know it at the time. As one example, things like leadership are not revealed in stats but can be in essays and recs.</p>
<p>Other schools may not weigh academics 50% of the admissions decision but it counts for a certain percentage. At CMU, academic review is only 10% of the decision to accept but even in that situation, when they are taking about 2-3% of applicants for the BFA program, and it is down to the final few, a student who has the "goods" on the application has a better chance than the one who doesn't have as good of an application package. At other schools, it counts more than 10%. Some schools won't even let you audition until you pass academic muster or in some cases, must be admitted to the school first. At others, the BFA program submits names of who they want after auditions, and the admissions office picks who they will accept from that list. I know at one school, in talking to an adcom about acceptance to the college but deferral on the BFA in the early round, they only held onto a small number who they were interested in artistically from the audition but who ALSO were strong academically. They certainly look at the application package. </p>
<p>It makes sense that they do. No, academics won't get you in if you have a poor audition. One must be admissable after the audition by the BFA program but when it comes to the academic part of the process, you gotta have what it takes for that particular school. At many of these BFA programs, students take courses outside of the BFA program, in the liberal arts areas. The university will want students whom they feel are appropriate for the college and can manage the schoolwork. Further, a student's abilities and work ethic spill over into simply being a student in any facet of their education, even in the BFA courses themselves. I work with a lot of students and it really shows who is a good student and who is a fair student. I see the level of work ethic, of ability, etc. even in what I do with them. I know the intensity of a BFA program and some might have difficulty managing it all if not a good student overall. </p>
<p>Anyway, I do believe the essays are important. They set one candidate on paper apart from another, in part, as often many applicants will have the requisite GPA or SAT for the school, but getting a picture of what makes each person unique goes beyond the numbers/stats. I have spent hours and hours each day and night this week helping kids with this very thing. I believe it is important. It won't get you in if they don't want you from the audition, but if theyare interested in you from the audition, better be able to be admissable by the adcoms, and be favorable in a pile of other artistically talented applicants who also interested the BFA program based on their audition. I would never suggest not doing a tip top job on applications, essays and every other facet of the admissions process when we are talking very very low admit rates at these programs. Everything counts. Why wouldn't you put the best possible foot and package out there? Not only that, the essays are the one thing, besides the audition, that really reveal a lot about your personality, more than numbers do. Colleges accept PEOPLE. Adcoms at schools that have BFAs, at least many I've visited, and that my kid applied to, talked about reading the essays. If they didn't matter at all, they wouldn't bother with them. </p>
<p>Susan</p>
<p>PS, as someone who went through this process with my own child, I can tell you she put a LOT into every application indvidually.....wrote many many different essays and other supporting documents and recs and various other things that went the extra mile. I cannot claim what factors resulted in her positive admissions outcome, but I wouldn't want to find out, or in other words, have her ever have risked not doing her best at both school and on the applications and all they entailed.</p>