<p>A parent who was looking for colleges with pretty predictable chances of admission asked elsewhere in cyberspace about colleges that mostly consider test scores, or possibly just test scores and grades, without considering a lot of extracurricular activities. That got me thinking about how my son has gradually begun to put a college application list together, and how a different family might put one together. </p>
<p>To respond to the parent’s question, to find reasonably decent colleges for which admission may be based mostly on test scores, or at worst test scores plus grades/class rank, first look at my List of “Outstanding” or “Noteworthy” Colleges</p>
<p><a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/437362-still-looking-college.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/437362-still-looking-college.html</a> </p>
<p>and then exclude most of the colleges that use the Common Application,</p>
<p><a href=“https://www.commonapp.org/CommonApp/Members.aspx[/url]”>https://www.commonapp.org/CommonApp/Members.aspx</a> </p>
<p>all of which pledge to "Consider subjective criteria in the admission process, including requiring ALL the following:</p>
<li>An untimed essay of at least 250 words or an untimed graded paper;</li>
<li>A recommendation form from a school-based counselor and/or teacher that allows the recommender to make substantive written comments on the form or in an attached letter;</li>
<li>Information allowing you to select a diverse student body."</li>
</ol>
<p>That would zero in on colleges (they will mostly be state universities) that make admission decisions based mostly on test scores, perhaps, or more likely test scores and grades.</p>
<p>That said, I wouldn’t build a college application list that way.</p>
<p>Here’s how my son and I, talking back and forth over the last few years, have developed successive drafts of his application list. He has attended quite a few [regional</a> information sessions](<a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/389153-where-students-can-meet-college-admission-officers.html]regional”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/389153-where-students-can-meet-college-admission-officers.html) for different colleges that visit our town jointly or individually to recruit students. Among those, some have caught his interest more than others. Almost all the colleges that have the recruiting budget to do that much travel are highly selective, well endowed colleges with need-blind admission policies and a guarantee of meeting full financial need (important to us, although some of those colleges still “meet need” with loans–boo! hiss!). Here and in various places online I have asked about colleges that have strong programs in my son’s current areas of interest. One thing I do to get a reality check on colleges is look up syllabuses for specific first-year courses my son might take if he enrolled at that college. Colleges vary quite a lot in how they present the “same” course. They also vary a lot in how many extracurricular activities they have related to my son’s interests. </p>
<p>EVERY college application list should be built from a “safety” college on up. I have defined a safety college as one that</p>
<p>1) is pretty much certain to admit the applicant, based on its known behavior in acting on admission applications,</p>
<p>2) has a strong program in an area the applicant is interested in,</p>
<p>3) is affordable based on its known behavior in acting on financial aid applications,</p>
<p>and</p>
<p>4) is likeable to the applicant.</p>
<p>We are fortunate that our state flagship university fits the definition of a “safety” college for our oldest, being an essentially sure bet for admission, strong in my son’s interest areas, affordable, and fitting to his tastes. Each family may choose a different “safety” college, but always that is the first college to put on an application list.</p>
<p>Once the safety college was determined, my son then considered other colleges whose road shows he has visited. He has had two favorites for more than three years now, one selected because of its cool road show (and some other good reasons) and the other selected DESPITE its really boring road show the first time we saw it. Both of those colleges are “reaches” in terms of admission probability, as they are hard colleges to get into even for the best prepared students. Both ought to be affordable if what they say about their financial aid is to be believed. Both practice “holistic” admission–one uses the Common Application, and one uses its own in-house application, but they agree in explicitly considering a lot of other factors besides test scores. Most of the other colleges my son expects to apply to now use the Common Application–one that formerly didn’t will begin accepting it next year–and even a college of interest famous for its hard-core reliance on grades and scores claims to consider issues other than scores and grades, although it certainly looks a lot more “by the numbers” than any other Common Application college.</p>
<p>Another issue to consider when applying to colleges is the order in which to apply. Right now (mid-winter 2008), many families are in suspense, waiting for news about regular decision applications that were submitted at the turn of the year. The National Association for College Admission Counseling (NACAC) discourages colleges from accepting applications before 1 October of a student’s last year of high school, but our state flagship university wastes no time in accepting applications right after that date. Indeed, State U offers “on-the-spot” admission evaluation to students who were previously enrolled in dual-enrollment or accelerated secondary math program classes, and the base admission rate of such students is 97 percent. We’ll eagerly await admission news from that college in October 2009. Then the fun begins. Some colleges are similar to State U in offering a “rolling” admission cycle, which means the earlier you submit your application, the earlier you get news about the result. Other colleges offer an “early action” round, with an application deadline of 1 November and a notification to the student by 15 December of the result–admit, defer to regular round, or deny. Most highly selective colleges offer a regular decision round that may have a deadline as early as November (various state universities) or at the turn of the year (the great majority of private universities). By NACAC rules, notification of regular decision results (admit, wait list, deny) has to come by 1 April, so the student can reply by the national reply date of 1 May if the student receives more than one offer of admission.</p>
<p>This timing builds a contingency into my son’s application list. He will apply to State U at earliest opportunity. If he is admitted to State U, he need not look for any more “safety” colleges. (If one has planned right from the beginning in defining a “safety” college, it should be sure-bet safe, and then one only needs one “safety.”) Then he will apply in fall 2009 to whatever subset of his colleges of interest that have NONBINDING early action admission programs. He’ll have to have those applications in by 1 November 2009. He’ll get news about those colleges by 15 December 2009. If he is admitted to NONE of those colleges, then it’s back to the drawing board for an expansion of the application list in the regular round. If he is admitted to one or more of the early action colleges, at least one college will drop off his regular round application list. (That college, as of today, has a binding early decision round but no early action round.) Certain colleges of interest have switched this year or may switch next year to a single-deadline admission system in which all applications are received and acted on in the regular round. (Harvard and Princeton operated that way this year, for the first time, as did the U of Virginia.) If those colleges are on my son’s list, he will apply to them knowing results from other colleges already. He’ll make the call about where to apply as results come in and he needs either to expand or to contract his application list.</p>
<p>I’ll paste in a NACAC quotation about admission cycle terminology below. To sum up, I think a well prepared high school student can get into a good college</p>
<p><a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/437362-still-looking-college.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/437362-still-looking-college.html</a> </p>
<p>and some, with careful planning and steady preparation, have a nontrivial shot at getting into the most selective colleges around. I don’t worry overmuch about what particular admission criteria a college claims to have. My son has his own schedule of activities and household chores, which he pursues because of his interests or our family needs, and not to build “hooks” for college admission. My friendly advice, which any reader of this is free to disregard, is to apply widely. Apply to any college of interest. (I agree that there is no reason to apply to a college unless your child might like to attend it, but there is no reason NOT to apply to a college unless attending it is absolutely repugnant to your child.) After applying, compare offers of admission and offers of financial aid to see what makes sense for your family. You always have until 1 May of each year to decide where to attend. </p>
<p>NACAC descriptions of admission programs:</p>
<p><a href=“http://www.nacacnet.org/NR/rdonlyres/9A4F9961-8991-455D-89B4-AE3B9AF2EFE8/0/SPGP.pdf[/url]”>http://www.nacacnet.org/NR/rdonlyres/9A4F9961-8991-455D-89B4-AE3B9AF2EFE8/0/SPGP.pdf</a> </p>
<p>Non-Restrictive Application Plans: All of these plans allow students to wait until May 1 to confirm enrollment.</p>
<p> Regular Decision is the application process in which a student submits an application to an institution by a specified date and receives a decision within a reasonable and clearly stated period of time. A student may apply to other institutions without restriction.</p>
<p> Rolling Admission is the application process in which an institution reviews applications as they are completed and renders admission decisions to students throughout the admission cycle. A student may apply to other institutions without restriction.</p>
<p> Early Action (EA) is the application process in which students apply to an Statement of Principles of Good Practice Interpretations of Mandatory Practices institution of preference and receive a decision well in advance of the institutions regular response date. Students who are admitted under Early Action are not obligated to accept the institutions offer of admission or to submit a deposit prior to May 1. Under non-restrictive Early Action, a student may apply to other colleges.</p>
<p>Restrictive Application Plans: These are plans that allow institutions to limit students from applying to other early plans.</p>
<p> Early Decision (ED) is the application process in which students make a commitment to a first-choice institution where, if admitted, they definitely will enroll. While pursuing admission under an Early Decision plan, students may apply to other institutions, but may have only one Early Decision application pending at any time. Should a student who applies for financial aid not be offered an award that makes attendance possible, the student may decline the offer of admission and be released from the Early Decision commitment. The institution must notify the applicant of the decision within a reasonable and clearly stated period of time after the Early Decision deadline. Usually, a nonrefundable deposit must be made well in advance of May 1. The institution will respond to an application for financial aid at or near the time of an offer of admission.</p>
<p>Institutions with Early Decision plans may restrict students from applying to other early plans. Institutions will clearly articulate their specific policies in their Early Decision agreement.</p>
<p> Restrictive Early Action (REA) is the application process in which students make application to an institution of preference and receive a decision well in advance of the institutions regular response date. Institutions with Restrictive Early Action plans place restrictions on student applications to other early plans. Institutions will clearly articulate these restrictions in their Early Action policies and agreements with students. Students who are admitted under Restrictive Early Action are not obligated to accept the institutions offer of admission or to submit a deposit prior to May 1.</p>