How vital are "additional homeschool requirements" in an application?

I’m putting together my ED/EA applications now, and I was wondering how important you guys think it is for homeschooled applicants to “nail” their additional requirements.

For example, Northeastern University is one of many schools I’ve seen that requires subject tests from homeschooled applicants. I’m a little anxious about these tests, because I struggle a lot in SAT subject tests. If I were to receive “just okay” or “mediocre” scores on my subject tests (600-700, for example) how badly would you think that would impact my admissions chances? It’s an interesting thing for me, because although most traditional students look at my ACT score (34C) and say that I’d be a shoe-in for some of my target schools, these additional requirements have me nervous. My other homeschooled friend has told me that he thinks these requirements are just a way of showing that schools are conducting due diligence, and they can’t actually hurt you.

I figure that as a homeschooled applicant, you would be scrutinized to a greater degree than others. Wouldn’t that mean that these sorts of additional requirements (which most traditional applicants would throw in as a ‘why not’) would be scrutinized the most? I mean, if that is the gauge by which an admissions office will determine whether you’re a “real” or “mommy grades” homeschool student, right? I’m not sure what to make of a lot of these.

Whatever you make of them, if a school to which you’re applying requires them, you’d better do your best on what they require. With a 34 ACT, I dont’ think it would be a deal breaker to get between 600-700 on subject tests for Northeastern, but of course it depends on so many factors.

My own son’s SAT II scores got lost the year he applied EA to Northeastern, and Northeastern waitlisted him (he had a 2230 SAT). Once they received his scores (730 Math II and 710 Lit), he was admitted. They are definitely serious about the supplemental information.

Some schools just want more objective proof. Can these extras hurt you? I suppose so if they aren’t up to par with other applicants.