OK, I’ll be the first to admit it. We hired a consultant.
At first, I was sort of against the idea, but my wife felt strongly we should hire one. Her sister (who has one child two years older than our twins and another the same age) hired one and swore by it, and part of me was thinking my wife was not going to be outdone by her sister. But at the same time, when we’d ask our kids “Where do you think you’d like to go for college?” we were getting a lot of “I dunno”.
So we hired one locally (and didn’t use the one my sister-in-law recommended) for the purpose of helping our kids develop a list of potential schools (and not the other things, like help on the essays). And I will say, to us he was worth the extra cost. In our first meeting with him we learned so much about the college application process and how it has changed so much since my wife and I went to college so many full moons ago. He taught us about the differences between Early Decision, Early Action, and Regular Decision, as well as the concept of “demonstrated interest”. [Note: it was while I was Googling info on schools he recommended that I first learned of College Confidential.] He reviewed our kids transcripts, gave each child a private lesson on the search tool in Naviance to help them research schools, and privately interviewed each of them to get to a feel for their preferences/interests. This, I think, was extremely valuable as he was able to get our kids to open up and tell him things that they might have been reluctant to say to us (like, Dad, I don’t see myself going to Ivy League school.) After the interviews, he made some suggestions regarding standardized testing, and went off to research some schools for us. A short time later, he sent us lists of schools for us to consider based upon the expressed preferences for geography, size, and major, taking into consideration selectivity and our kids’ records to date. After we had visited some he had recommended (and after more test scores and grades came in), he added a few more for us to consider.
All in all, we think hiring the consultant was worth it. We did college visits to nearly all schools on the recommended lists, and the kids found schools they love. Both kids applied ED and were accepted to their top choices. DD went 6 for 6 on her acceptances (five of which she didn’t submit any SATs or ACTs), and was offered very generous merit awards on her safeties. DS went 3 for 4 on his acceptances with one waitlist (at one of the two schools I forced him to apply to since I didn’t want him applying to only two schools. In retrospect, I don’t think his heart was in it when he had to write the “Why XXX University” extra essay.)
Perhaps I could have saved a few dollars had I known about College Confidential earlier, but along the way I learned a lot about the college application process and my kids are excited to be attended schools in the fall where I think the fit will be just right. So life could be a lot worse. 