<p>
[quote]
yea, no sht an editor helps, but i was talking about need, not some tiny marginal benefit from having one. It's the people who have bad writing habits who need an editor the most.
[/quote]
</p>
<p>I disagree. The people who are terrible writers probably aren't getting into top colleges one way or another unless people totally rewrite their essays (which I understand some pros do, though it's rather unfortunate). Someone who has a good draft essay and gets some extra help turn the draft from good to great is really improving his/her chances at a top college.</p>
<p>
[quote]
"As I said, I was serious. If OP paid me $400, I'd find the time. That's about what I value my time at"</p>
<p>then why are you posting here again? - i'd hope you aren't gaining $400 worth of utility every few posts. if that's your going rate why respond to people's querries? it clearly takes you time to read what they've written and respond.
[/quote]
</p>
<p>To to a good job editing a 500 word essay, it would be time consuming and require a great deal of concentration and brainpower. One can read and respond to posts in a few minutes during a commercial break when watching TV, during a cab ride or waiting at the airport or somewhere else where it's hard to be productive, etc. Apples and oranges.</p>
<p>
[quote]
"and it's far less than what others charge for this sort of thing. It's not nasty and an insult."</p>
<p>nope, people charge $400 bucks or so for high level interview training and a thorough resume examination. People will read essays for far less,
[/quote]
</p>
<p>Are you kidding? The college admissions "pros" charge $2000-$3000 (or way more sometimes) for the "full service" package, and often won't sell individual, a la carte services like essay reading. I've seen people like grad students advertise essay editing around the range of $200-300, but these people are generic and have no particularized college essay expertise.</p>
<p>
[quote]
there are ton who'd do it for free, or nearly free. so to ask for $400 is pointless and arrogant,
[/quote]
</p>
<p>There are a lot of things that people pay for even though they can be had for free. I think it's silly to pay money for an essay editing service; my parents didn't hire one for me, and I would encourage others to similarly seek out their high school teachers. But people are willing to pay for this sort of service, as indicated by the fact that such a huge market exists for it.</p>