Is My UChicago Essay Topic Appropriate?

I’m working on my supplement for UChicago and I just remembered this really awesome thing I did during my freshman year so I wanted to right about the topic “How did you get caught? (Or not caught)”

During my freshman year I helped pull off a spectacular senior prank. I was kind of central to the scheme since I provided them with a valuable item.

Anyway, after the seniors pulled their prank they confiscated the thing and I never got into any trouble since nobody believed that I did it (even after admitting it so I could get the item back) while the others were suspended for a week since most had a minor* disciplinary history and were pretty much average C students.

*cellphones in class, lateness, etc.

In my essay I want to discuss the prank and afterwards on how looking back at it over the years has made me aware of the kind of privilege I have that comes from being an A student that is able to follow rules without question and how that’s unfair since the purpose of an education isn’t about being an A student or learning how to follow rules without question so people shouldn’t be penalized for that kind of thing.

Yo bro, it’s just a prank dude… DUDE it’s just a … just a prank, man!

I kind of like it. But it depends on what the prank was… some result in property damage or worse, and you don’t want to get tagged as someone with poor judgement.

Had the same question. Doing the common app prompt about failure and specifically about getting caught doing something stupid. No harm done to anyone and never got in trouble, but it was still technically illegal as it was trespassing. Not sure if it is appropriate, but I just think I’m gonna roll with it as it is a story unique to me and I think that’s more important than a lapse in judgement in 8th grade.