I respectfully take a different view than the earlier comment about UT Dallas being just like other regionals. First of all, when I looked up the two examples provided, neither of them was ranked in the highly-competitive “National University” category. However, I found that UT Dallas makes a much better comparison in many respects to the top Universities of those systems (UMass & SUNY). As you’ll see below, UTD is comparable in numerous ways, and even surpasses those institutions in some measures. I will admit, if you only look at the US News rankings of National Universities, the three comparisons in this sample rank slightly higher. That particular ranking places a heavy emphasis on peer scores and research expenditures. There are a couple of reasons that UTD is not yet ranked higher in relative terms by these standards. First, many public “flagships”, are combined with a medical school. Medical schools typically are the source of 60-75% percent of research dollars at top tier publics (outside of Texas). They also are home to many of the Nobel Prize winners and members of the National Academies that weigh into the US News score. Thus, as two of the sample group below have medical schools, one would naturally expect them to be ranked higher than UTD by the US News criteria (possibly, much higher). Therefore, UTD being able to stand in the same company of these other fine universities, without a medical school, speaks volumes. When one also considers that UTD has been admitting freshmen for less than 30 years, it makes it all the more impressive. I wouldn’t rule out the possibility of UT Dallas and UT Southwestern Medical Center merging at some point in the future; which would immediately make this conversation moot as UTSW has one of the largest numbers of Nobel Prize winners on its faculty and research expenditures that would catapult the combined University into the realm of the most elite publics. Nevertheless, UTD currently does benefit from several joint efforts with UTSW and UTA and has the backing of the one of the wealthiest and innovative university systems in the world.
UTD has a tradition (albeit still lacking the 100+ years advantage that UMass has) of attracting highly competitive students. It has excellent faculty and its graduates are sought-after in recognition of their work ethic and discipline. No, UTD is not an easy school. During my time there I had to earn my grades. I competed with bright students who took their work seriously. Nevertheless, I made good friends, was active and loved my time there.
With the upcoming relocation of regional and national headquarters for Toyota, JP Morgan, State Farm, FedEx Office and Liberty Mutual just a few miles from UT Dallas, I can only imagine it will become more competitive for prospective students, more prestigious and the opportunities for graduates will be even brighter. I’d proudly pick UTD again today and hope that my daughter makes the same choice.
UT Dallas (Started admitting Freshmen in 1990)
SAT Middle 50 %ile 1140 - 1370
Nat Merit Sch. - 104
USN Graduate Business Ranking - 33
USN Graduate Engineering Rank - 76
Engineering Research Expenditures $46,280,989
Kiplinger -33
Bus Journals - 46
Times Higher Education World Rankings 201-250
SUNY Stony Brook
SAT Middle 50 %ile 1150 - 1350
Nat Merit Sch. - 11
USN Graduate Business Ranking - NA
USN Graduate Engineering Rank - 66
Engineering Research Expenditures $28,972.504
Kiplinger - 30
Bus Journals - 32
Times Higher Education World Rankings 201-250
SUNY Binghamton
SAT Middle 50 %ile 1210 – 1370
Nat Merit Scholars - 1
USN Graduate Business Ranking - Not Ranked
USN Graduate Engineering Rank - 117
Engineering Research Expenditures $10,191,714
Kiplinger (publics) - 22
The Business Journals’ Top Public Colleges - 18
Times Higher Education World Rankings 351-400
University of Massachusetts – Amherst
SAT Middle 50 %ile 1120 - 1310
Nat Merit Sch. - 2
USN Graduate Business Ranking - 74
USN Graduate Engineering Rank - 59
Engineering Research Expenditures $57,405,079
Kiplinger - 56
Bus Journals - 48
Times Higher Education World Rankings 141