<p>Thanks for your comments tjd…as I mentioned in an earlier post, the economy as well as students trying to gain admission to ND (and other top schools for that matter) was quite different over 4 years ago. I am sure that things have changed drastically with regards to how financial aid is handled, and further, ND’s ability to attract top students. I am quite confident that ND can interpret aid in any way they choose (private school), but I have to admit that there must be some “need” evident to begin with. In our case, it was not evident, and was not going to likely become evident, even tho our student had been identified as Reilly Scholar, Early Admit. I am certainly not discounting the fact that awards(not tied to need) may be given to students that demonstrate performance once enrolled, but I highly doubt that these awards are what I would consider substantial (except for Hesburgh)-and by substantial, a semester’s tuition, etc. Yes, ND can be very generous with financial aid, given there is some need (no matter how small) to begin with–I understand that part. But, there are some top students (or at least 4 years ago) who have no financial need that would qualify for pure merit awards at other schools. I think ND was sensing this–even back then and stepped up its programs to try to attract these kids. Yes, our student turned down several full rides at other schools, but we thought it was worth the sacrifice/cost for student to attend ND. And, at this point with graduation around the corner, we have no regrets! For others, I am delighted to see the Hesburgh program initiated. And as I stated in above post for new students, dig deep with finance office with regards to scholarships, esp if you are a top student with other offers in hand. ND has obviously recognized the deficiency that existed 4 years ago with regards to PURE merit for top students.</p>