Lewis and Clark vs. Whitman vs. Redlands

I am currently looking to transfer to these schools for the fall 2018 term from Portland State University, and I am having a hard time with choosing between the schools listed in the title. Currently, I am majoring in engineering, but I am changing my major to physics/mathematics, and I am also an athlete. I have recently been admitted into Whitman, but I did not get any merit scholarship money (which I was expecting), while I did get good scholarships at Lewis and Clark and Redlands. Each school has its strengths over the others, but they are all good choices for me which is why I am having a hard time deciding. I want to know what you guys think. I am highly considering academics, safety, housing, and location, outdoor activities, but I am not too big on the social and drinking scenes in colleges. I appreciate any advice!