Good point, @chillkitty about many competitive schools requiring ALL scores…and even what they mean by “all” scores varies…U of Penn, Georgetown, and Stanford (off the top of my head, there may be others) ALL require ALL tests ever taken (a complete testing history), so if you took SAT and ACT they want to see both. I don’t think that’s fair but that’s what they say (I just looked up Penn to make sure it hasn’t changed and it hasn’t).
So what is a good new SAT score? I agree this seems vague because the chart they published makes it seem like you need a 1560 to compete with a 35 ACT, which does seem a bit high (for the old SAT I think a 1540 equated to a 35). This is why I brought up the point about the 34.5 or 34.75…it just seems that the SAT scores are more detailed…it makes me wonder if some schools might actually bring the composites down to “quarters” when they are comparing scores in an attempt to be more fair?
I know if I were an admissions rep I would be quite impressed with a 1500 ish score on this new SAT given the fact that there has been very little material made available to help you prepare. I’m impressed with the fact that those of you that took the new SAT in March took it and did as well as you did. Whether or not you send your scores is going to have to be your decision based on all of the information available to you. When in doubt, this actually might be a good reason to reach out to the admissions rep that covers your geographical location and ask them what they think, and ask them if they will be using the concordance tables put out by the college board. Many schools will likely say send us everything and we will use whatever makes you look best, which I think they truly do. They are looking for reasons to admit you, not to not admit you so if you send a 35 ACT and a 1520 New SAT, I don’t think they will value that 35 ACT any less…but if you aren’t sure, maybe you can ask them. It might be a good way to get your name in front of them anyway (a topic for another discussion, do they track interest this way and does it help/hurt you?) Or just go with your gut and just send that ACT if you are more comfortable with that.
The truth of the matter is, none of us @mmk2015 (I’m assuming) have any real idea what goes on inside each admissions office or inside each admission rep’s mind when reviewing an app. All we can do is put forth the best possible application possible. We are all on this thread and CC in general because we are looking for support and advice. I think that we all would agree that we all have to keep in mind that there are a lot of opinions (many based on hearsay, but some of that hearsay might actually be valuable to hear) thrown around here. We need to all weed it out for ourselves and decide with the guidance of our parents/counselors/teachers what is the best strategy for our individual applications. And if very well may vary BY SCHOOL because they are all unique in how they view things (for example, Stanford WANTS the new SAT with writing!!!).
And here is what I wrote to begin with (you might want to note that I straight out say that it might not be true):
For what it is worth, and this may very well not be true, I have heard that there are some schools out there that truly prefer SAT…I have heard this about Ivies and Georgetown, in particular. With the new changes this year, who knows how they will feel about it.
So I agree, what I heard (and I did hear it from people in the know, trust me) may be a moot point this year (if not this year, definitely next). Now the new SAT is supposedly more like the ACT so if there were any hidden preferences in the past, one would assume they would be gone if the new SAT is truly more like the ACT.