<p>It’s hard to say exactly where you’ll stack up at these schools without knowing a little more about your stats. When you say your SAT “aren’t amazing” you might mean it’ a 2100, or a 1800, and that will definitely make a difference. Also, at these kinds of school, epically if your SAT is iffy, there is a difference between a strong GPA of 3.7 and a strong GPA of 4.0. Have you considered trying the ACT?</p>
<p>But, some thoughts: In general, Amherst and Dartmouth are reaches for everyone. Bowdoin, Middlebury, Vassar, Wesleyan, Colgate will probably also be reaches, thought perhaps a little less so, and Colby will probably be a little less reachy than them (maybe more a high match?).</p>
<p>Bowdoin and Middlebury are SAT optional, so if everything else abut your application is strong you’ll probably have a better shot at those two than equivalent schools where you have to submit your SATs; they also clearly value personal qualities. I also known that my school, Wesleyan, does value personal qualities, and I would suspect that most of these schools do. That makes them at least somewhat realistic reaches, but reaches none-the-less. </p>
<p>You might also want to check out Carleton, especially if you’re not from the Midwest. It fits right into your list as a midpoint between Amherst/Middlebury and Wesleyan/Vassar on the “quirky students” scale. Furthermore, while still being a very selective school, it tends not to get as many applicants form the coasts as its coast counterparts purely because of its location. In my experience (from watching my casemates), this means qualified students are more likely to get in at Carleton than its east coast counterparts, because they are looking for geographic diversity. Plus, it’ an awesome school.</p>
<p>You might also want to check out Grinnell, which is another great school that is easier to get into because of its location (to a far greater extent than is true of Carleton). It also fits right in to your list. </p>
<p>Some other schools that would be low reaches/high matches or matches or safeties that seem to fit into your list: Bates, Oberlin, Kenyon, Skidmore, Goucher, Dickenson.</p>