Mechanical Eng. PhD topics

<p>Hello guys,</p>

<p>This is my first post but I have been reading here for a few days. Let me just introduce myself breafly. I went to school (BS and MEng) at Lehigh University. Finished BS in 3 years and Master in 12 months. I like studying and would like to think that I am smart. Because I was in a rush, I graduated with a relatively low GPA (3.3). I have been thinking about doing a PhD. I made a decision. I want to do it. I made a quick list of places I want to go to. But I know that will change. the thing is: I have no idea what topic I want to research. I have no idea what are the topics available. I want to do it in ME but still open to aero/astro, space, nuclear. </p>

<p>How would i go about solving that problem?</p>

<p>Get research experience. You need the experience to get into a PhD program and figure out what you want to do.
Did you get a chance to do any research while speeding through your BS/MEng? If not, you will probably need to take a job doing research to get the necessary experience and start to narrow your interests. If you did do some research, what caught your attention the most?</p>

<p>I didn’t do the typical research experience. I had a couple of Independent Study courses in my BS and MS where I did optimization, cost analysis, and feasability studies regarding a solar energy storage application. Wasn’t interesting. </p>

<p>I know I was good at polymer processing stuff but wasn’t my favorite. Same with manufacturing</p>

<p>My favorite is automotive stuff especially powerplants. I am a motor head but I realise there isn’t much cut edge interesting research in internal combustion engines anymore. I would love to work on alternative energy solutions for vehicles etc. I also love jets. This is connected to thermodynamics in general which I loved and did really well. </p>

<p>I did well in and like fluid dynamics but I hate CFD. I also don’t like turbulent flow because i just don’t understand it. </p>

<p>I didn’t do well at in Nuclear reactor engineering but i thought it was the most epic course i have ever had. It was like watching star wars all semester. </p>

<p>Undergrad heat and mass transfer was OK. But I did really well in my masters, although it was extremely extremely challenging. </p>

<p>I wrote all that stuff above because I think that is where I should begin. But I really have no idea. </p>

<p>I don’t think the option of getting research experience is possible for me at this stage. There just aren’t any opportunities to do that.</p>

<p>Do you have much work experience? Sometimes that can somewhat cover for a lack of research experience as an undergraduate.</p>

<p>TBH, I don’t think you should get a PhD because you do not know what you want to do.
How do you know you want a PhD if you don’t know what area you want to go into? What is your motivation for a PhD? A PhD is a LONG COMMITMENT. 5 YEARS (at least) IS A LONG TIME. </p>

<p>What you said about liking fluids, but hating CFD doesn’t really make sense. Computations is a method of solving physics. What do you not like? You state that you like fluids, so I assume you do not like the computational approach? This approach is not for all. It is very heavy in complex math (i.e., numerical methods), which I suspect is also why you do not like turbulence? Whatever you do then, don’t go into computational turbulence (it’s arguably the most complex area you can possibly pursue).
The way you stated that (i.e., hating CFD) is as if you think fluids is all about CFD, which is far from true.
Maybe look into experimental/theoretical fluids work (though I suspect you may not like theoretical research). I don’t know what you don’t like about turbulence, but if you want to model a realistic system, there is always turbulence. It’s ubiquitous, so maybe fluids isn’t the area for you.</p>

<p>And btw, the superficial knowledge of CFD you may have incurred during your undergrad is nothing like what research in CFD may be. </p>

<p>Look into controls&dynamics research if you insist on going to graduate school.</p>

<p>Within your posts, you kinda go back and forth and I’m kinda confused on what you’re saying. “I have been thinking about doing a PhD. I made a decision. I want to do it.” What?
From your posts, I have no idea why you would want to get a PhD. All I’m seeing is “I want to get a PhD because I want to.” But I don’t know the first thing about you.</p>

<p>And how’d you make a quick list of places you want to go to without identifying which research area you want to pursue? Because if you just went down USNews rankings and picked the top 20, I’ll be brutally honest and say that you will likely not get in to any of them.</p>

<p>Why do you want to do a PhD if you have no idea what you want to study and don’t have any research experience? You don’t even know what you are getting yourself into at this point. A PhD is a research degree - you spend 5-6 years doing research primarily, and the purpose is to get a degree so that you can do more research as part of your career. If you have no experience now and aren’t passionate enough about it to be creative and think of ways to get more, how can you possibly be dedicated enough to commit to a career in the area?</p>

<p>Grad programs don’t admit people to PhDs on the basis of them randomly deciding one day that they want to do it. Think about it like a job. Most employers want to hire someone who has experience doing the exact thing or something very similar to what you will be doing in your new role. At the very least, they want someone with transferable experience.</p>

<p>PhD programs invest thousands of dollars in their doctoral students - tuition waivers, health insurance, and your stipend, plus all the overhead it takes like your equipment, travel funds, office space, etc. The cost to fund you alone can easily cost nearly $250,000 or more depending on the price of your school. They do it in hopes that you will bring recognition to their school - by finishing the program, publishing scientific articles, impressing your colleagues at conferences, winning grants, and going to be a prominent faculty member or industrial/government researcher elsewhere. All of that is about research prowess, and the best way to predict who will be good at that in the future is by looking at what you did in the past related it and how successful you were. Why would they bring you into their program when they could bring other students in with 2-4+ years of research experience?</p>

<p>I’m not saying this to be rude or discourage you, but I’m saying it to say that you need to be both thoughtful and creative about this enterprise.</p>

<ol>
<li>First you have to decide why you really want the PhD. The only acceptable answer (unless you are independently wealthy and just have loads of time to waste) is because you want a career that requires a PhD, either as an engineering professor or the head of an academic, industry, or government lab in your field, or something like that - that involves directing research. If your answer is anything other than that - especially anything like “I want to learn more about engineering,” “I want it for the prestige,” “It’s a dream of mine,” - you probably should NOT go. It’s far cheaper, in terms of opportunity cost, to get an alumni membership to Lehigh’s libraries or otherwise get access to some academic library and read more about engineering, and perhaps attend a few conferences every year.</li>
</ol>

<p>This is, of course, unless you don’t mind the losing the earnings you will miss out on (plus the retirement savings and free time), as well as incurring the mental/emotional distress, during the 5 or 6 years a PhD takes you - all for the purpose of earning a degree that you don’t need and probably won’t lose.</p>

<ol>
<li><p>If you do decide that you want the PhD, then you need to decide what you want to study. Usually #2 comes before or in tandem with #1 - as in, students get research experience, they fall in love with research in some area, and they decide “I want this to be my career.” You need to find something you are passionate enough about to do for a long time and really dive into. Thinking about what classes you liked in college and your MS is a good start. If your favorite is automative stuff, then you need to find a way to dive into that. I’m sure there is still interesting research in that area - alternative energy solutions is a big one; I’m not even an engineer and I know that that’s a big field right now. The way to find out is to read scientific articles in the field and talk to some of your professors doing research on automotive stuff. What are they studying? What are their colleagues studying?</p></li>
<li><p>Only after you decide #1 and figure out #2 can you begin to put together a list of programs to apply to. That’s because your programs need to based upon your research interests. You have to go somewhere where there are at least 2-3 people doing something that you would be interested in and in whose lab you would like to work. The reason I say 2-3 is because your first choice could die, leave the university, get denied tenure, leave academia altogether, etc., and you want to be able to stay in your program and transition to working with someone else.</p></li>
</ol>

<p>Juillet,</p>

<p>Thanks a lot for all that valuable advice. I appreciate it. </p>

<p>I have been working in a corporate environment for 3 years now. I had 2 different positions over that period and I did well in both. But I just can’t find myself doing this. I really don’t like it. It doesn’t feel scientific or engineering. Just people running around trying to do stuff and once in a while resort to science. I don’t like that. </p>

<p>I liked the technical scientific stuff we did in college all the time. I also enjoy every seminar and conference I have. And always feel like I really wanna be like one of these Dr. that are doing this interesting cutting-edge technology stuff. So that’s what I feel like I really want to do. </p>

<p>Maybe I should consider another Masters? MS instead of MEng where I will focus on research more and then I can find out exactly if that’s for me or not. </p>

<p>What do you think?</p>

<p>Have you considered looking for a position that gives you the kind of challenges that you a looking for? perhaps in an R&D environment. Working in such a place might help you determine whether you really want to invest the time in an other advanced degree. I agree with the other posts and doing a Ph.D. should not simply be for lack of anything better to do. It is too much of a sacrifice in earning power and time.</p>

<p>I have been trying to find a job in an R&D environment. It’s been a year and half so far with no luck at all. So that option did not work very well for me. </p>

<p>I am extremely not pleased with my current career direction and I don’t want to waste more time doing something I know is not for me. </p>

<p>I was able to secure full funding for a PhD program which makes it much easier to do, financially, at least. </p>

<p>If it turns out to be such a bad idea, which i highly doubt, I can always just get a masters and look for a job. I am looking at different research subjects and if and only if i find something I fall in love with (after reading many journals and papers about) i will persue it. I have given myself 1 year time to do that. If i don’t find anything, i’ll find plan C or D. </p>

<p>So I want to get some advice on where I can look up research subjects and cutting-edge technology stuff so I can find exact things of interest.</p>

<p>You’re asking us where to find Mechanical Engineering research subjects. Honestly, most of the people in here aren’t even engineering majors. That’s something you need to go find yourself and not have someone spoonfeed you very basic information you can easily obtain. Just how motivated are you?</p>

<p>I honestly don’t know why you keep on insisting you want to get a PhD when you have no idea what you want to do nor do you even know where to look for mechanical engineering research subjects.<br>
You also don’t seem to be taking in much of the advice in here.</p>

<p>You mentioned in the OP that you already have a list of schools you want to apply to. Has it crossed your mind to actually look at these schools departments and their research areas?</p>

<p>Yes, I’m trying to be a mean and I don’t care.</p>