What do you want to study?
If you have a pretty good idea, get ahold of a good guide like Rugg’s Guide and compare schools that are very strong in your areas of interest (could be more than one) with the size and location of schools your prefer.
From what you have said so far, I agree with Dickinson, think Haverford might be a reach, Davidson also a reach, Elon a solid fit, Bowdoin a reach too. St. Olaf a match, Carleton another reach.
The Trinity school mentioned up-thread was Trinity U in San Antonio, where I think you were thinking the College in Connecticut. The former is another solid choice, if you are interested in studying in Texas, and it is urban.
Rhodes is a match, also urban.
But the area of interest might help winnow down the list of prospective schools for you.
Good luck!