Otterbein College

<p>Long-time readers know that I have rarely posted the name of my school. I see my role here as something of a reporter, not as an advocate for my program. It just wouldn’t be appropriate. </p>

<p>But since our audition season is about to begin, and since many of you will be visiting, I thought it would be useful to have a place to talk specifically about Otterbein. Once I get this started, I plan to stay out of the conversation, except to answer specific questions. I will continue to post elsewhere on more general topics. </p>

<p>The first post, to follow shortly, will be about our audition and selection process.</p>

<p>Warning: it's a long message, and cc.com has told me that it's too long for one post. So I'll break it in two. Herewith part one:</p>

<p>Since our first audition is a week from Saturday, I thought it might relieve some anxiety for students and parents if I described our process. I’ve written about aspects of this in many places over the last year, but it may be helpful to put it all in one document.</p>

<p>On-campus</p>

<p>We ask everyone to arrive by 7:45 a.m. on Saturday morning. I wish we could start later, but there are just too many things to do. We start in the Battelle Fine Arts Center, which houses our largest dance studio and the Music Department’s recital hall. Families are met by Harriet Hill, our department assistant, whom many of you have talked to about arranging the audition, and Debbie Byrne, our new Admissions liaison. We do provide food and water. </p>

<p>At 8:30, the auditioners join Stella Kane, our Director of Dance, in the dance studio. She spends about 15 minutes leading everyone through a warm-up, then spends the next 20 minutes teaching the group a jazz routine. Intermediate level, not higher. She then looks at everyone in groups of four. She asks about previous training, and will ask those with training to demonstrate their technique, pirouette, pull backs, whatever they’ve studied. We’ve talked about how other schools do very difficult dance calls, and we don’t see the point. Stella can tell about someone’s dance training in about 30 seconds, just as a good voice teacher can hear voice training from scales. (We don’t need to hear “Glitter and Be Gay” to recognize a coloratura.) Also, we’re not interested in demonstrating how challenging our program is, or intimidating auditioners. We want to see their best work, and we believe we’ll see that if we can make them comfortable enough to take risks.</p>

<p>At 9:30 we gather everyone in the recital hall for an information session, which I lead with Dennis Davenport, my colleague from the Music Department. He’s a pianist, composer, and conductor. We try to describe all aspects of the program, curriculum (theatre, dance, music and Integrative Studies) and productions, internships and showcase, in 25 minutes. It really can’t be done, but we talk fast. Well, I do. He’s from Tennessee.</p>

<p>(We also try to remember to thank the parents for supporting their kids in what they want to do. We are acutely aware that we wouldn’t be able to put our kids through college if you weren’t choosing to put your kids through college.)</p>

<p>Then we divide the auditioners in half. One group goes off to take the music test. It’s pretty simple. We want to know if students can match pitches and rhythms, and if they can read music. We have admitted students who can’t read, but not students who can’t match pitch. We don’t do a piano test. Students admitted to the program will be placed appropriately when they arrive. </p>

<p>The theory test doesn’t take too long, and we try to arrange tours of our theatre facilities after the test. Our proscenium theatre, Cowan Hall, has just undergone a $1.4 million renovation—not a lot of money, but we spent almost all of it on acoustics, and the change is remarkable. I can’t wait for those of you who’ve visited before to hear the difference.</p>

<p>The other group stays in the recital hall to do their vocal and acting auditions. They get to hear each other. We’ve occasionally thought about changing that. But there are some advantages, including having a supportive audience. The kids really support each another. And we think it’s good to have someone besides two late-middle-aged white guys for them to play to.</p>

<p>We have a professional accompanist, Eileen Huston, who will have looked over the students’ music before the audition (while they’re dancing). She knows all the standard pieces, but if she has questions, Harriet Hill will get Mrs. Huston together with the students to answer them. In any case, students have a minute with Mrs. Huston on stage before they do their audition.</p>

<p>The audition for us is 16 bars of a ballad, 32 bars of an up-tempo, and a monologue, preferably from a play, the total not to exceed four minutes. These are guidelines, not rigid rules. If the first verse of a ballad is 18 or 20 bars, that’s fine. But we don’t need to hear all 19 verses of “Green finch and linnet bird.” Students are free to do the pieces in whatever order they wish. I recommend that they lead with their strongest piece. In theatre, as in court, primacy is the rule. Human beings remember the first 15 seconds of a new event more than any other part of an experience.</p>

<p>Harriet keeps time. We give auditioners a grace period, but we do stop them if they go past 4:30. By then we’ve heard what we need to hear. Other than for going over on time, we don’t stop actors in the middle of their auditions. There’s no deduction for this; it’s not ice skating.</p>

<p>We videotape all the auditions, because we want to go back and look carefully at the end of the audition season. More about this later.</p>

<p>At the back of the recital hall are several people: me; Dennis Davenport; Stella Kane; Dennis Romer, our Artistic Director; and Karen Eckenroth, Director of Vocal Music. Debbie Byrne and Harriet sit in as well. Other schools put faculty in different rooms; I guess they rate students separately and combine scores later. But we like to watch the students together, because after they’re all done, we get to talk about them. We don’t always agree, but I have confidence in our collective judgment. Another reason for having everyone together is that we can discuss appropriate placements for each student. Some will be right for Musical Theatre, others for Acting, or Vocal Music, or the Dance minor, or the BA Theatre program. We don’t necessarily know enough from the audition, but we can make initial assessments and then follow up in the interview. </p>

<p>While the students are auditioning or taking the theory test, we hold sessions for parents in another building. One is about student life, and the other is about financial aid. We try to help. We also find it helps to have parents elsewhere when their kids audition.</p>

<p>At around 11:30, we switch groups, and starting around 1:15, Dennis Davenport and I begin interviewing each student. We may only get 7 or 8 minutes with each one, but we find out a lot in that time. We’ll talk to them about their dreams, their previous training, their favorite role, what they see as their strengths and weaknesses, what they hope to learn in college, why they’re interested in us, where else they’re applying. (It’s no sin to be applying lots of places—as anyone reading this board knows, no one can afford to put all their eggs in one basket.) Then we may do some work. I may do some actor-coaching, Dr. Davenport may suggest singing a song at a different tempo or in a different style, whatever we think will help the student connect to the piece in a deeper way. We don’t choose to work with everyone; it depends on what we think we need to know. If we’ve seen it all in the audition and the interview, that will be enough. There’s no point in trying to read into “he worked with me”, “he didn’t work with me” in terms of your chances of being admitted.</p>

<p>We provide lunch in the Campus Center either before or after the interview. And that’s it. Students and their families are free after the interview. If students have to get home for a performance that evening, all they have to do is let Harriet know that, and she’ll rearrange the interview times. We do encourage people to stay if we have a performance in the evening—it’s one of the best ways for you to assess our program—but we realize that not everyone can.</p>

<p>Continued....</p>

<p>The Unifieds</p>

<p>These are different. Instead of everyone auditioning together, we give each student a 20-minute appointment. We usually talk first, then look at the audition, then work with the student, then answer questions about the program. Sorry, but auditioners have to bring their accompaniment on tape or CD. I wish I could afford to hire accompanists in every city, but we’re just not that rich. Everything on the road is put on videotape, just as at home.</p>

<p>Dennis Davenport, Stella Kane and Debbie Byrne come with me to Chicago. Stella takes the students through a dance audition, and she’s become a master at getting people to look good on carpet. Dr. Davenport may work with a student on a song, just as he does on campus, and I’ll do the same kind of coaching on the road that I do at home, if I need to. Debbie can talk to students and parents about college issues, including financial aid. </p>

<p>In NY and LA, I’m hoping to have an alumna or a senior MT/Dance major with me to teach a dance combination to the auditioners. It will be appropriate to each student’s level. In San Francisco, I’ll ask dancers with previous training to simply demonstrate some steps for me. Stella gives me a list of what she wants to see, and she looks at the tapes.</p>

<p>The Selection Process</p>

<p>Because we only have room for 8 MT majors and 8 Acting majors in the freshman class, we have to make some very difficult decisions. We always have many more qualified students than we can admit. That’s one of the reasons we put the auditions on tape. At the end of the season, in mid-March, we go back and review them, and try to choose a class. It’s very much like choosing a company for a play. We want diversity. We don’t want everyone to look alike. What’s the point in admitting eight women who are all 5’5” blonde sopranos who look 16 on stage? They’ll spend the next four years competing for the same roles and hating each other. We’d like one of each, please. So our first offers go to the 16 whom we think would make the best class, looking at it from every point of view, talent, castability, desire, work ethic, intellectual curiosity, soul, and fit. Some very gifted people would not do well here, and we try to avoid those mistakes.</p>

<p>At the same time, we know we’re not going to get all of our first choices, and that’s why we use a waiting list. At the most, there will be 8 on that list for MT (and 8 for Acting). It's not a list that goes from 1 to 8. Rather it’s a list that has 8 alternates, one for each spot. So if our first choice 5’ blond soprano decides to go elsewhere, we can go to the alternate 5’ blond soprano. Being on the waiting list is not a bad thing.</p>

<p>We send out all our letters at the same time, this year by March 21. Harriet and I do all of them. Our financial aid office does its very best to get financial aid packages to families right after our letters go out, so that you know what you're looking at. We ask students to give us an answer by April 15, if they can, so that we can go to students on the waiting list if we have to. But we can’t demand an answer before May 1, which is the agreed-upon decision date for colleges across the country. If students are still waiting to hear from other schools, we can usually extend the deadline. </p>

<p>Enough. I’m at 1930 words so far. I hope this helped. If you have questions, feel free to post them, or to write to me privately. My contact information is in my profile; just click on my screen name.</p>

<p>Thanks, everyone. I look forward to seeing those of you auditioning for us. And best wishes to all of you on all your auditions. Be of good cheer. Breathe. And let yourself be excited about this! It's a great time in your life.</p>

<p>doctorjohn</p>

<p>Thank you for your thoroughness, DrJohn. I will print this off for my daughter to ease the tension....though having been on campus with you all before, her tension will be negligible! We're grateful for your help.</p>

<p>Thanks for posting such an in-depth description of your audition process. I'm sure it will relieve a lot of anxiety for many students. It sounds like you run a very humanistic audition. I'm glad to hear that you tape the auditions. I must admit to being surprised that out of the 7 schools my D auditioned for last year, only one school (CCM) used videotape. We knew beforehand that CCM taped the auditions. We assumed that surely all of the schools that did not use rolling admission and even most that did (because of the necessity of waiting lists) would want to have the auditions on tape. I don't know how auditors can rely on written notes alone to make decisions about candidates weeks after the auditions have taken place. Kudos to Otterbein!</p>

<p>I can only wish that all other program directors (and their programs) were as enlightened as you are DoctorJ. Just think how the anxiety level of all involved would drop if they had the kind of information you have provided, not just in this wonderful post about your audition process, but in all of your other posts on this site. Bravo!</p>

<p>Pssssssst.........CC readers........if you want a REAL treat, email Doctorjohn and ask to see a copy of the Otterbein Misson Statement. (Don't kill me, Doc - they need to see it....) It's masterful and will make you realize how much difference a quality program can make in the OVERALL educational lives of all of our budding performers. It's a lucky group that ends up in Westerville.</p>

<p>Theatermom, I'm with you...the mission statement of the Department of Theatre and Dance is well worth reading. Here's the link: <a href="http://www.otterbein.edu/dept/THR/brochure.htm%5B/url%5D"&gt;http://www.otterbein.edu/dept/THR/brochure.htm&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p>

<p>DoctorJohn, you are truly amazing. My D will appreciate your post. Thank you</p>

<p>Doctorjohn, thanks once again. I'm so impressed that Otterbein HAS a mission statement for its theater department. And the description of the two auditions is invaluable. Now you will see some kids (from THIS board) where at least part of the tension has been removed. They know what to expect. That means you'll see better auditions, I'm willing to bet. Thank you!</p>

<p>You are the best. I wish that everyone provided as much information to prospective students.</p>

<p>Doctorjohn, I have a question about the Chicago audition. Im confused on wheather or not there will be a dance audition in chicago. I know that theres an improv thing for the dance minor, but will there be any dance for just MT auditioners? Also if there is will it be one on one with Stella Kane?</p>

<p>mtfan:</p>

<p>Yes, there's a dance audition in Chicago. Stella will be there, and she works with each student individually. She'll ask about your training and then give you a combination at your level. No music, just a few steps. She may ask you to demonstrate other steps, if you've been trained. If you haven't, don't worry. She'll be able to tell your aptitude, and that's the most important thing we're looking at in any case. OK?</p>

<p>Awesome! thats all I needed to know! Thats exciting that she'll work with us one on one!</p>

<p>Incredibly enlightening posts!! Thank you!!</p>

<p>Drjohn - Thank you. Theatremom is correct. Nerves are really diminished with this thorough information.</p>

<p>doctorjohn - You said "some very gifted people would not do well here, and we try to avoid those mistakes." You have already given so much but could you elaborate on that a little? Are you talking about kids with diva attitudes and whatnot or are there other things? "Too strong for the ensemble," "too into different genres than what we do," "too advanced an academic student to fit into the college culture," "would leave to work before she graduated," "incompatible prior training," etc.? I always wonder what different schools are looking at when they think about "fit." A very talented friend of mine got rejected from a school everybody thought would almost be like a safety for her and we are sort of in 'go figure' mode about it. I also have a couple of friends who will be auditioning for you in Chicago.</p>

<p>Good questions, notarebel. Your guesses about what schools find incompatible are correct, and all those things have come into play in our decision-making from time to time. But there are other things as well.</p>

<p>Let's start with your good friend who was turned down. I'm going to assume she goes to school with you, and that you both attend a fairly high-powered pre-college actor training program. Some colleges feel that students like you have already taken the equivalent of their first-year curriculum, and consequently find themselves impatient in their freshman year, so impatient that they transfer out after a year, or even a single term. Or worse, they've stayed, but their impatience has infected the rest of the class. If that has happened to a college more than once, the faculty may be reluctant to take the chance with applicants who have had extensive training. Quite simply, you can be too trained for some college programs. Not all, but some.</p>

<p>Our concerns at Otterbein are different. I personally like students who've had good training. But a bad match for us is a prospect who tells me that he is interested in liberal arts courses--an important part of our curriculum--when he really just wants to take acting classes and be on stage. It isn't always easy to diagnose that from a brief interview, and sometimes I get fooled by a gifted actor who is also a good liar.</p>

<p>Another troublesome match is someone who discovers too late that Otterbein is just too small, or doesn't have a challenging enough intellectual atmosphere, or is too far away from home. Luckily, most students who feel those things know it within their first ten minutes on campus. That's why I strongly encourage students we've admitted to come to Westerville before they make their final choice. I've lost some great talents as a result of a campus visit, and I hate it. But I'd rather lose them before they come than after a year, when we've both invested a lot of time and money in a relationship that didn't work out.</p>

<p>Some of these things wouldn't be an issue for other schools, because they take enough students that they can afford to lose some, and/or they're willing to cut the ones who aren't keeping up. We don't do either, because we're a group of stubborn teachers, and we hate giving up on anyone. So I feel a significant amount of pressure--all self-generated--to make excellent choices. Finally, I have to trust my instincts, the work I do with actors in the audition, and what my colleagues see at the audition or on the videotape. </p>

<p>Does that help?</p>

<p>doctorjohn- Yes that helps a lot. Thank you!</p>

<p>I haven't posted for awhile - mostly lurking - but had to respond to Doctor John's post. Our visit to Otterbein was the best of all that we had. We felt special, welcome, comfortable and yet not "given a line." Doctor John (who rearranged his schedule to accomodate our plane schedule) was really honest with my S and me about the tough odds of these programs and talked to us a bit about other programs in our area (Wisconsin) that would be good alternatives. We got a "sneak peek" at the theater contruction in progress and a look at a typical freshman schedule. We got to sit in with the students an listen to an agent from NYC who is a friend of Dr. John's give a an incredibly funny (and insightful) talk about what to expect when looking for an agent and auditioning. My S whipped out a notebook and wrote furiously just like he was a senior about to graduate from college! We were almost late for our flight because we didn't want to leave. But my S came away feeling there were a lot of options - although Otterbein would be his first choice, he applied and has been accepted to two non-audition programs and is auditioning at three programs some would say are "second tier" but look to have solid programs and some good results. He is resolved to be happy with wherever he ends up.</p>

<p>Am I allowed to brag a little about my kids?</p>

<p>So Stella (Kane, our Director of Dance), Dennis Davenport (our MT teacher from the Music Department) and I were just finishing up auditions in Chicago yesterday when Stella's cell phone rang. I doubt any of you know that Dan Knechtges (BFA MT '94) choreographed the new William Finn musical, The Putnam County Spelling Bee, which opened off Broadway on Monday night. It got a rave review in the NY Times--</p>

<p><a href="http://theater2.nytimes.com/2005/02/08/theater/reviews/08putn.html?pagewanted=2%5B/url%5D"&gt;http://theater2.nytimes.com/2005/02/08/theater/reviews/08putn.html?pagewanted=2&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p>

<p>... and has been extended to March 20--</p>

<p><a href="http://www.playbill.com/news/article/91099.html%5B/url%5D"&gt;http://www.playbill.com/news/article/91099.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p>

<p>So anyway, Stella answers the phone, and it's Dan. Turns out that the producers, Mr. Finn, and James Lapine, who directed, met with the Shuberts on Wednesday afternoon--mind you, a day and a half after the opening--and the show is going to Broadway in April!</p>

<p>Dan was so happy. He can see his debts evaporating (he'll have a piece of the show), and he won't have to live on peanut butter ever again.</p>

<p>We're incredibly proud of him.</p>