Physics- Pomona v. Columbia?

College Search & Selection
1

*In case you’ve seen this post before, I’m posting in multiple forums in order to reach the maximum amount of people; I’d really like feedback on this issue!

I’ve been accepted into both Pomona and Columbia and I’m conflicted as to which to go to. I’m planning to major in physics or astrophysics, and then go on to grad school- at the end of the line, I’m aiming for a teaching position at a college or university. Right now, I’m conflicted because I know I would love the environment at Pomona, but at the same time, I’m not sure how Pomona’s physics program compares to that of Columbia (I’ve heard plenty about how Pomona excels in all fields of study, but I haven’t found many discussions on physics in particular). I’ll be doing campus visits of both colleges in April, but for now, I’d still like to hear some additional opinions. Could current (astro)physics students at either school give me some insight as to what it’s like to study physics there?

Some questions I’d like answered (though any additional information would also be greatly, greatly appreciated!): how accessible are your professors? How easy is it to find research positions, even as an underclassman? How big are your classes? In general, why study physics at your respective school?

If you have anything else to weigh in about the two schools, just in general (atmosphere, lifestyle, etc.), I would greatly appreciate any kind of insight you have to offer.

Thanks in advance!

2

As I just wrote in another thread–ask the admissions office to put you in touch with some professors and undergrads in the physics departments at both schools. Ask them about research opportunities for undergrads. How many students take advantage of this? When can they start–freshman year, sophomore, later? What kind of research are they involved in? Where do they end up for grad school? How about summer work?

For Pomona, you’d also be able to cross-enroll at Harvey Mudd. Talk to professors and students on that campus, as well.

You can also ask professors in each department what they’d do in your shoes.

3

If you end up at Pomona, the offerings at HM are amazing for more class options. My DH did his undergrad in Physics there and then did his PhD at Caltech (and was super well prepared). He did a ton of research (both on campus and in summers). I did a Biology/Math Double at CMC and took Physics (for Physics majors) at Pomona (along with several math classes) and really liked the professors