Please help me choose! IU vs. WashU

Hi everyone — I’m a high school Senior, and I’m really torn between Indiana University (my state school) and WashU in St. Louis. My main interest is premed (biochem major), and I’m planning to minor in Spanish (for medical Spanish). No matter how I turn the schools over, I can’t come up with a decision. Here are the pros and cons I’m considering in choosing the schools.

IU

Pros:
1. They have my doing the summer research IFLE program, where I would spend six weeks during the summer on campus doing research full time with a staff member who I would be working with for my 4 years at the school.
2. They are offering me a full ride (tuition AND room and board).
3. I would already know some upperclassmen from my high school, so I would already be aware of many premed/shadowing opportunities through these connections.
4. I would already have a strong social group (in theory) starting off through the summer research program.
5. They offer a really cool Freshman IFLE class that involves a brain dissection, a lot of practical lab work, and that is research-oriented.
6. They allow you to keep a car on campus.
7. I would be in the Top 5% at the school most likely, so I feel it would be easier to secure opportunities on campus (the big fish in a small pond phenomenon)
8. Through my research, I’d be able to stay in the IU med system.
9. With 50,000 students, I’m sure I could find my niche.
10. Every time I’ve been on campus, I’ve just kind of got a good feeling/good vibe from the place.

Cons:
1. I’m not into the whole party/drinking culture, which IU is very well known for.
2. I would know a lot of people from high school — I guess I’m afraid I’d stagnate.
3. It doesn’t have the prestige/wow factor that WashU does, especially in pre-med.
4. There aren’t as many hospitals in Bloomington as there are in St. Louis.
5. I would be rooming with someone random, which I’ve heard can lead to some pretty weird roommates.
6. People seem to move out of the dorms after Freshman year, which is a little intimidating to me

WashU
Pros:
1. They are offering me a full-tuition scholarship (leaving 16000 a year for room and board, which my parents can pay)
2. They have some truly cutting-edge research, although there is no guarantee I could be a part of it.
3. Their premed advising is outstanding.
4. They have a premed class designed to teach you about being a doctor and help you gain shadowing.
5. The kids there are all really smart, and I feel I could learn from them.
6. The classes are definitely more rigorous than IU’s (although I have heard IU’s honors and IFLE classes are challenging).
7. There’s a pre-orientation with some other scholarship kids, so I would have a community through that.
8. I already know someone who is interested in being my roommate.
9. The school has an affiliated Spanish-speaking medical clinic which would be perfect for medical Spanish

Cons:
1. I don’t know if the rigor of the classes is compatible with what I want in college — I don’t want to drink every night, but I would like to be able to attend cultural events and relax with friends without constantly stressing about homework.
2. I’m worried I may get left behind with all the other really smart kids.
3. It’s farther from home (4-hour drive, day-long plane trip), which is scary to me.
4. No cars on campus for freshmen.
5. I just don’t get the same good feeling that I do from IU

I don’t know, objectively, WashU seems like the place that is better for premed, but IU just feels better (and that could be because it feels safer). Also, (and I wanted to mention this all separately of the other factors) I have a girlfriend who is younger than me, and going to IU would make relationship stuff much easier (visit every 3rd weekend for a day, for example). I love her, but I don’t think she has the grades to get into WashU, and I’m afraid I’ll be kicking myself for ages if she ends up at IU and I’m at WashU.

So, what do you all think? Any personal experience with both these schools?

Some feedback on your analysis:

  • IU is large enough that you’ll find a non-drinking/non-partying group of friends and will meet plenty of new people so that you won’t feel stagnate with your high school acquaintances
  • WashU wouldn’t have admitted you if they didn’t feel you could handle it…prepare to fine tune your time management skills and you’ll be able to enjoy plenty of cultural events and time with friends, and you won’t be left behind in the coursework
  • Remove your younger high school girlfriend from your decision tree. Both you and she need time to explore who you are and what you want to do with your life. There’s plenty of time for reconnecting and pursuing a serious relationship later if you both want that. You’ll be demonstrating great maturity and respect for her by recognizing this.
  • You mentioned “intimidating” and “scary” a couple of times…these are perfectly normal feelings. You’re about to embark on a big new adventure. You’ll make mistakes, you’ll learn, you’ll grow, and then the next chapter of your life will begin and you’ll again have similar feelings.

You sound like an intelligent hard worker. You have great options and there are no wrong choices here because this is the story of your life, no one else’s. Make a decision, seize the day, and move forward with 100% enthusiasm and no regrets!

Agree with all above. Will add that even if your parents can afford the extra $64,000 + to go to Wash U that money will go a long way to reducing medical school debt to follow. With IFLE as an IU bonus, I’d have trouble turning down their full ride offer.

Thanks for your feedback – I guess one of my main concerns is any possible difference in the quality of IU’s and WashU’s academics. Can anyone comment on this?

Premed will be very challenging no matter what, and regardless of where you attend, you will not be able to relax at night except on weekends. As a premed, your first three weeks you’ll see other freshmen go out every night. You won’t be able to do that, regardless of where you go.
Sounds like IU is a great opportunity for you and that it’s the University you prefer even as you’re trying to justify to yourself why you should choose prestige.